"Redskins" is out.
In the 1960s and 1970s the term "Native American" had largely replaced "Indian" or "American Indian" as the respectful term to describe the indigenous people in the Americas. Then something happened. The words Indian and American Indian began coming back into greater use. A new cultural rule had emerged. The polite and respectful term to use for groups within our culture is the term the people in the groups prefer and use for themselves. It turns out that many Indians preferred Indian.
Jack Mullen and Jennifer Angelo |
That rule of courtesy has a Golden Rule feel to it. Do onto others as they would have done to themselves. If male homosexuals want to be called "gay," then "gay" it is. The word "Latinx" was invented by non-Hispanics out of good intentions to be inclusive and non-offensive, but its use is fading. The reason is simple. Hispanic Americans didn't prefer it or use it themselves.
Indians--Native Americans--didn't call themselves "redskins."
Jack Mullen was two years ahead of me at Medford High School. We thinned and picked pears in summer jobs together as youths. In our 20s we worked together as field representatives for a Democratic U.S. Representative. He and his wife recently moved from the Mission District in San Francisco to a home in Washington, D.C. Jack Mullen and his wife, Jennifer, are sports fans.
Jack played on teams wearing a "Medford Black Tornado" logo. Medford residents can cheer "Black Tornados" because we don't have tornados here. Tornados are a far-off peril, not a cause of local death and misery. No one is offended.
Guest Post by Jack Mullen
As a long-time friend of Peter, I am flattered when he occasionally asks, now that I live in Washington D.C., to give an inside the Beltway perspective of all things Washington.
Yes, we in Washington still worry about all things emanating up and down Pennsylvania Avenue. We worry about covid and non-maskers. But you know what really gets up in our grill these days? The embarrassing conduct of our once proud, but no longer called Washington Redskin football team.
1965: Catching a pass
Not that we expected to play in yesterday’s Super Bowl XLI in the obscenely opulent So-Fi Stadium in Los Angeles. Although the football team remains rather dull, apparently there was not a dull moment inside the football team’s offices and facilities. Female office workers, as well as members of the rally squad, told Congress last week of the belittling experiences of constant sexual innuendos they had working under owner Dan Snyder’s umbrella, including advances from Mr. Snyder himself.
If a healthy dose of misogyny wasn’t enough, General Manager Bruce Allen was caught on tape yukking it up with Oakland Raiders coach John Gruden about African American players who had ‘big lips’.
Dan Snyder was in need of public relations help and decided, after a decade of relentless public pressure, to drop the name Redskins. Washingtonians, chuckled, then took to the interim name, ‘The Washington Football’ until a committee could come up with a new name. Before you knew it, fans were yelling “Go Football Team” as checkers at our local Safeway did every Sunday in the fall. “Football Team” became an endearing nickname as it stood out against bland names like Lions, Eagles, Cowboys, or any other nickname of other NFL teams. Ok, 49ers is pretty cool, but still.
Washington football fans new found energy quickly disappeared when, after 16 months, the committee decided only military names would befit a rough-tough football team. So, on February 2, the name Washington Commanders was unveiled with appropriate hoopla.
Now headline writers short on space, have to refer to the Commanders as ‘Commies’. Fans have taken to call fellow Commander fans in the new Commander jackets, ‘Comrade’. And what about the Native Americans who despised the nickname “Redskins”? The new name reminds them even more that it was the military the practically caused their extinction. Way to go, Dan!
14 comments:
The Romans provided combat at the coliseum for the masses for free, and threw in a sandwich. The genius of the modern Caesars is they get the mob to pay, including parking and $17 beer. Also now, as then, seating is based on status.
Fun facts: "The American Gaming Association estimates that more than $7.6 billion will be bet on the Super Bowl this year." Roughly one in five pathological gamblers attempts suicide, a rate higher than that for any other addictive disorder.
Go Commanders!
It wasn't the American military that practically cause the extinction of Amerindians. It was their vulnerability to smallpox from domesticated animals.
I find the new name offensive because it evokes colonialism and subjugation, as in the O'Brian titles, "Master and Commander: The Far Side of The World".
I figure the best name reflecting Snyder's capitulation is the Thinskins, not to include the healthy majority of Indians polled who are fine with Redskins.
I think the Racketeers would have been more representative of the city.
And don't forget that Medford's own "cultural appropriation" back in the day was reflected in their football helmet stickers that said "BLACK POWER".
How about TheWashington Woke? :-)
Haven’t seen that “1/5 pathological gamblers commits suicide” stat previously, but Oregon government reliance on lottery revenue and voters’ support for it is predatory.
******
It’s a bit ironic that more than ever we insist on calling so many other ethnicities by “color” (partly accurate, if that) ~~ black, brown, white. I guess yellow got tossed, and now red, but the rest are ever elevated. This will pass someday (that I won’t live long enough to see).
*******
“The word "Latinx" was invented by non-Hispanics out of good intentions to be inclusive and non-offensive, but its use is fading. The reason is simple. Hispanic Americans didn't prefer it or use it themselves.”
Hispanics prefer Hispanic, not Latino. Latinx is a NON-WORD in any language, including Spanish, invented by self-anointed elites in the media, who are mostly concerned with virtue signaling to each other.
NPR has become largely insufferable.
“NPR has become largely insufferable.”
Indeed they have! Woke virtue signaling for liberal affluent white women. I mainly listen when my day has not been annoying enough.
NPR is insufferable to those who are annoyed by facts.
A little addendum to dudgeon’s comment on the military:
The U.S. government authorized over 1,500 wars, attacks and raids on Indians, the most of any country in the world against its Indigenous people.
Mike is insufferable to those who are annoyed by semantically empty snark and passive-aggressive sniping.
So, you do believe that some contagion diseases can be deadly? Or do you think smallpox was also invented by Dr. Fauci?
Funny, I read your comments when my day hasn't been annoying enough.
It's better than the comics!
True.
Genocide. And carried out by the US military.
Mc--
No. Not true. Words and definitions matter to those for whom precision in language also matters.
The word is "genocide". The U.S. Army killed a mere fraction of the number lost to smallpox. Not genocide.
Actual genocide is mass killing with the deliberate aim to erase a group. Smallpox was cruel happenstance.
I should add since we have plenty of fabulists here: the deliberate smallpox-blanket infections is a fable.
The only reference thereto was from Lord Amherst, before the Revolution. Even he never carried it out.
I don't know if the age ranges match up, but a lot of leftists here appear to have read Zinn and believe him.
Low Dudgeon-
You sound mighty convinced of your opinion, but actual scholars have considered it debatable for a long time:
https://daily.jstor.org/how-commonly-was-smallpox-used-as-a-biological-weapon/
Post a Comment