Saturday, December 18, 2021

Profiles of the Capitol rioters

     "JEREMY says 'Just made it into the Capitol here. Oh yeah, oh yeah. It gets no better than this. Freedom. God bless America.'”

            Criminal Complaint, U.S. District Court


Six Oregon men were among those arrested for being inside the Capitol on January 6.


The six are among the 705 people whose cases are reported within a data set of public information: https://seditiontracker.com  To see suspects organized by state click https://seditiontracker.com/suspects/by_state

Identified as Jeremy Grace

The site displays a mug shot or photos within the Capitol, a several-page criminal complaint, plus any motions filed by the prosecution or defense relating to bail. The criminal compaint is authored by the law enforcement person who observed the defendant in the Capitol or who examined the photographic and telephone records surrounding events that day.

Jeremy Grace: White Power gesture
The criminal complaints are formal and deadpan. They outline evidence that the defendant was illegally in the Capitol and the multiple offenses that act involves: Trespass, destruction of property, assault. The complaints put the actions into a broader context. The January 6 riot was not frat-pledge high jinkshi-jinx or random vandalism. The rioters were there intentionally disrupting an act of Congress.

The complaints summarize like this:

Based on the foregoing, your affiant submits that there is probable cause to believe that HUBBARD violated 18 U.S.C. § 1752(a)(1) and (2), which makes it a crime to (1) knowingly enter or remain in any restricted building or grounds without lawful authority to do; and (2) knowingly, and with intent to impede or disrupt the orderly conduct of Government business or official functions, engage in disorderly or disruptive conduct in, or within such proximity to, any restricted building or grounds when, or so that, such conduct, in fact, impedes or disrupts the orderly conduct of Government business or official functions; or attempts or conspires to do so.

The drama in this data set comes from the deadpan description of the events surrounding each defendant's actions. The complaints describe the method of identification of the defendant by a unique hat or scarf or sometimes a bare-faced photograph, descriptions of throwing a bicycle rack or barricade or some other act of violence, and what the defendant might have said or textedThis is from the indictment document for Richard Harris who was living out of his car, but if given bail would return to his father's home in Happy Valley, Oregon

A still photograph (from a video) clearly shows Defendant, unmasked and with his arm upraised, addressing a masked, uniformed police officer. The Government proffered that Defendant told the officer that the police were outnumbered, that there are “a f***ing million of us out there,” and that they were “listening to Trump.” . . . 

Aware that he was being filmed, Defendant then spoke into the phone, asking where Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi was, adding, “We’re coming for you, you b***h!” He also asked where Vice President Mike Pence was, stating, “We’re coming for you too, you f***ing traitor!” 

Two brothers, Jonathanpeter Klein, age 21, and Matthew Klein, age 24, had long records of involvement in Proud Boy activities. They were already in law enforcement's attention from their attacks on the Oregon Capitol. The Complaint included:

31. J. KLEIN entered the Capitol Rotunda. While there, J. KLEIN engaged in another celebratory exchange with PERSON 1 during which J. KLEIN greeted PERSON 1 by declaring, “proud of your f***ing boy!”

32. J. KLEIN and M. KLEIN exited the Capitol. After exiting the Capitol, J. KLEIN and M. KLEIN worked in coordination to forcibly open a secured door on the Capitol’s north side. Federal law enforcement officers were visible on the other side of the door while J. KLEIN and M. KLEIN took this action. 

Like the other complaints, it concluded that their various acts were part of a broader conspiracy "to impede and disrupt the orderly conduct of Government business and official functions."

Identified as Richard Harris

I invite readers to follow the links and peruse the record. For myself, I perceive:

---These defendants were caught up in a movement, and then on the afternoon of January 6, a moment. They were believers in Trump and the Stop the Steal goal. January 6 in the Capitol was a period of excitement in transgression and hope. A universal quality to the texts and quotations by people in the Capitol was thrill

---These defendants were willing, enthusiastic pawns in Trump's bigger wish to overturn the election, but they were not disciplined soldiers in that effort. They were on their own, having fun, part of a rowdy crowd with no direction or leadership.

---They were dangerous, but they didn't think of themselves as criminals. They were proud of themselves, which is why they took selfies and called their friends while the riot was taking place.


12 comments:

Mike said...

Let’s not forget the Oregon Republican Party issued an official statement claiming the insurrection was a “false flag” operation staged to discredit the GOP and silence Trump’s supporters, so I’m sure Republicans will agree these dangerous idiots should have the book thrown at them.

Low Dudgeon said...

There are six Oregonians, not five, and none appears to be from Oregon’s Republican sectors, Southern and Eastern Oregon. Maybe those Willamette Valley and North Coast cats just have more spleen or more steam to let off. The Happy Valley fellow had no fewer than three federal public defenders working on his motions!

Up Close: Road to the White House said...

Corrected, thank you L.D. I combined the Kline Brothers in my mind. Six, not five, as i first posted.

Rick Millward said...

It's an interesting thought exercise to try to imagine what is going on in the brains of these characters. Not much.

While it's abundantly clear that these boys are wit disadvantaged, there is increasing evidence that the attack was planned in advance. One of them recently was sentenced to five years in prison. His defense was that he was being punished unfairly.

Palmer said in a handwritten letter to the judge that he felt betrayed by Trump and his allies who fed them conspiracy theories.

“Trump supporters were lied to by those at the time who had great power," he wrote. "They kept spitting out the false narrative about a stolen election and how it was ‘our duty’ to stand up to tyranny.”

Palmer, ...said "it wasn't fair that he be punished so severely when the ringleaders aren't even behind bars."


The basic question is whether or not the attack was a plot by Republicans, including some in Congress, which is a crime. It would seem that Trump's actions, his delight and that of others, his reluctance to try and stop it, (possibly out of fear that he couldn't) is suspicious. All but two Republicans opposed an inquiry, also suspicious.

Lots of folks taking the fifth.

While it's true the rioters believed they were acting honorably, what's most disturbing is the extent of the delusions that allowed them to be so easily led, by those the majority of us see as frauds and scammers, just as guilty but smart enough to avoid the body cams.

Anonymous said...

Even given that criminals are usually not smart, these selfie taking defendants do not see themselves as criminals. They are restorative nostalgics. See Anne Applebaum’s book, Twilight of democracy, the seductive allure of authoritarianism. They are attracted to authoritarianism because they dislike complexity and diversity. They are deluded zombie autonomons. they believe themselves to be true blue American patriots. Yes, it is thrilling as sh*t to be a patriot fighting for freedom against the cabal. Or at least that is easy to believe.

Ed Cooper said...

If somebody more intelligent and organized than el Bloato had been in charge of the attempted Coup, we might well have seen the destruction if the Republic that day in January. As it turned out, it became a dress rehearsal, and I strongly suspect that the real powers behind this movement learned enough that the next time, they're going to succeed.

Michael Trigoboff said...

While we are holding people responsible, another group to look at is the officials who were in charge of defending the Capitol. How is it that a disorganized mob of morons was able to invade that building? Why were the Capitol Police so understaffed? Why was there so little coordination with the DC Police or the National Guard? Who made those decisions? Will they be held accountable?

We are always going to have morons. Are we also doomed to always have incompetent officials?

Mike said...

Mr. Trigoboff asks some very pertinent questions. A 9/11-type bipartisan commission could have answered them, but Republicans scuttled that idea, making you wonder what they've got to hide. Oh, never mind - we know very well.

Malcolm said...

MT, probably yes. Don’t forget the Peter Principal. Besides, we’ve all witnessed this disaster, if we’ve had many dealings with bureaucrats.

Ed Cooper said...

Has Mr. Trigoboff seen, or acknowledge the reports that the National Guard was prevented from interfering by Micgael Flynn's (convicted and pardoned felonious General) brother, also a General Officer.

Michael Trigoboff said...

edc,

I didn’t know that. Throw the book at him.

Mc said...

So, you think banks should be blamed when they are robbed?

After all, if the bank was closed it couldn't have been robbed.

Or maybe the clerk at a Minute Market should fight back harder.

Good to know.
When you're house is robbed we'll blame you for living there.