Sunday, March 13, 2022

Sacrifice for Democracy

     "Ask not what your country can do for you. Ask what you can do for your country."

If only.
Today's Guest Post asks us to imagine.


Imagine if Americans would unite on behalf of democracy in Ukraine by sacrificing for the common good. Imagine if people would willingly turn down their thermostats to 68, or carpool, to nudge down the price of Russian oil. Imagine if U.S. corporations willingly reduced their profit margins to share in the national sacrifice.

Rod Kessler is a college classmate. He is a retired professor of English at Salem State University in Massachusetts, where he coordinated their creative writing program. He suggests that Biden ask Americans to do just that.

Rod Kessler

His Guest Post is not parody. It isn't a creative piece with an unreliable narrator, a clueless Ichabod Crane character who had been asleep during the COVID crisis and misunderstands the world he awakened into. Sacrifice for Ukraine? Unify? Why a third of Americans wouldn't get a vaccination to save their own lives and to keep emergency rooms available in their own communities. A third of Americans support the insurrection to overthrow a democratic election here in the USA. This isn't a JFK world where  Americans will "pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship. . . to assure the survival and success of liberty."  It's a "Let's go, Brandon" world.

Rod's kind of earnest hope isn't naive. It is nostalgic. Rod's advice to Biden holds up a mirror to Americans. It shows us what we lost.

Guest Post by Rod Kessler

Let me start with the obvious: Whether we hear about rising gas prices on the news or directly at the neighborhood filling station, it’s no secret that the war in far-away Ukraine is impacting us at home. Because we have little stomach for sending in American troops to protect Kyiv, we’re putting the big squeeze on Putin’s Russia economically. But given globalization and our interconnected economies, we can’t clobber Russia’s economy without inflicting pain on our allies’ economies and on our own.

If I were in Joe Biden’s shoes, I’d already be asking my fellow Americans to willingly shoulder some of the economic burdens. I’d ask us all to consider lowering our thermostats by a degree or two to reduce demands on our energy supplies — and to lower our monthly fuel bills. If you like a 68-degree setting, try putting on an extra sweater and see if you can handle 67. Right now, such a sacrifice would be patriotic.
Likewise, can we car owners find ways to drive less or even reduce our speed to conserve and cut costs? Most of us would get a health boost from actually walking more. If the price of a gallon skyrockets to $5, could we conceivably make car-pooling work? Are we as a people capable choosing public transportation when we have the option? (Imagine the new slogan: When you ride the T, you give Volodymyr Zelenskyy a lift!)
 
A younger Rod Kessler

Doing so would be patriotic.

Naturally, what’s true for gasoline and fuel prices is true for food prices too, what with the threats to Ukrainian wheat production. Yes, it’s already tough going at the checkout counters in the grocery store, but if I were in Joe Biden’s shoes, I’d be asking us to consider it our duty to adjust our diets to stay in synch with the foods that are still plentiful and affordable. Let’s have more new slogans: Eat beans and stick Putin with a gas problem.

Doing so would be patriotic.

Ours is a divided society, and half of us are happy to lay the blame for inflationary high prices on the Biden administration. Some Americans won’t go along with anything that the Biden White House proposes. Despite that, Biden hopes to promote unity. Maybe the situation in Ukraine will help us to reunify. If I were in Joe Biden’s shoes, I’d already be asking my fellow Americans to deal with a little sacrificing right now.
But I wouldn’t stop at asking only ordinary people like you and me and the rest of us fiddling with our thermostats or tanking up at the filling stations or pushing our carts at Market Basket. I’d be asking our huge corporations to share the costs of the crisis too. I’m talking about Mobil and Shell and National Grid. I’m talking about Archer Daniels Midland and Cargill and General Mills. I’m talking about Walmart and Safeway. Consider: when the price of gas and food rise, it’s not an act of nature. Corporations ultimately determine prices, and they do so, understandably, with an eye on the bottom line. In case you haven’t noticed, corporate profits have been healthier than ever, undaunted by the pandemic or by inflation.
To put it another way, those at the very top of the economic heap are somehow managing to do very well. But what if they too were expected to do their bit to make sanctions work? What if they could put the profit motive aside, even for just a little while?

Imagine how our day-to-day economic lives would change if our largest corporations decided to tighten their own belts and run on just half of their usual profits (or at cost!) for the duration of the conflict in Ukraine! Imagine the headlines: Amazon slashes prices until Putin withdraws. Imagine if up and down the supply chain for fuel and gasoline production all players agreed to proceed at an at-cost and zero-profit basis until the crisis ended. Costs for all of us would settle down. Talk of inflation would end. and we’d all be sharing the burden of the patriotic sacrifice for standing up to Putin, with his tanks and missiles and bombers.

If I were in Joe Biden’s shoes, I’d be on the phone right now with a bunch of corporate boardrooms. Doing so would be patriotic.

21 comments:

Mike said...

The Greatest Generation sacrificed a hell of a lot for us. They risked their lives in war, endured rationing and paid high taxes to reduce the debt after the war. Their taxes also supported affordable public education. Their offspring (that would be us) seem neither interested or capable of that. Besides, we lack the leadership.

What are the odds that Americans would be willing to sacrifice for Ukraine’s democracy when we can’t even defend our own? The ringleader of our 2020 coup attempt remains not only at large, but the leader of a so-called political party. Yesterday he was calling on Republicans to “lay down their very lives” - not to defend democracy but to fight against Critical Race Theory, their racist dog whistle for Black History. I think that tells us all we need to know about their interest in unity.

Michael Trigoboff said...

I would support higher taxes to increase our military readiness and our military support for Ukraine. I would support sending Ukraine whatever weapons they need to fight the Russians. I would support taking effective steps towards energy independence like reopening the Keystone XL Pipeline and those drilling leases that Biden stopped.

World War III may be spinning up right now; we need to be preparing seriously.

There are totally valid objections to the adoption of curricula based on CRT in K-12 schools that have nothing to do with opposition to the teaching of black history. Gratuitous accusations of racism regarding those objections are like crying “wolf,” a tactic which ultimately stops working. No one is scared of imaginary wolves; the r-word is losing its sting thanks to woke rhetorical overreach.

The old Tea Party had a sign that said, “it doesn’t matter what this sign says, because you’ll call it racist anyway. “

Ed Cooper said...

When will Mr. Trigiboff lose his delusions about the the Keystone XL contributing to anything but Canadian Pipeline owners bank accounts ?
Give it up Sir, you lose more credibility everytime you repeat that canard.

Mike said...

I think the Tea Party sign that summed them up best was:
"GET A BRAIN!
MORANS"

Mike said...

Point of information:
Claiming to be combatting “CRT,” an imaginary boogeyman supposedly afflicting our schools, some states are passing laws against teaching racial history in a way that creates “discomfort” among white students. If Black history doesn’t make us feel discomfort, we have no heart. If we fail to teach it, we have no brain. It’s the American equivalent of holocaust denial.

Michael Trigoboff said...

The objectionable parts of CRT-influenced curricula have to do with laying a “white privilege” guilt trip on school kids. That’s the problem, not anything to do with accurately teaching history.

Michael Trigoboff said...

edc,

Canadian oil going via Keystone XL to US refineries increases domestic oil supply. How is that “a delusion?”

Michael Trigoboff said...

Mike,

When you call people morons, it doesn’t help your credibility when you misspell the word. Just saying…. :-)

Michael Trigoboff said...

I started my original post to this thread with what I was willing to do for the common cause, which would be in addition to the cryptocurrency donation I just made directly to the heroic Ukrainian fighting government.

I don’t mind debating among ourselves, having grown up in the very argumentative culture of 1950s Jewish Brooklyn, but it would be good to hear what everyone else is doing to advance common causes like freedom and standing up to naked depraved aggression.

Low Dudgeon said...

I hope some regular readers here are able to grok, however contrary to the customary inclinations of some others, that obstinate, ignorant and repetitious certitude is hardly the exclusive province of conservatives. Then again, perhaps reassuring oneself with the mutual support and proud declarations of the similarly limited is in fact the primary object of that exercise.

Granted it is no easy task for everyone to immediately grasp that the physical location of oil and natural gas, for instance Houston versus Sevastopol, plus the economic, social and political amenability of the respective international owners and sellers, may well have a predictably marked effect on prices and a sustained, reliable supply, today and in subsequent years.

Nor should those of us accustomed to a balanced diet to include articles and books in addition to simple starches like social media and cable TV soundbite expertise, judge too harshly those content with such low-nutrient repasts. Those unfamiliar with Critical Theory, for instance, can hardly be expected, absent humility and self-awareness, to address its permutations.

I myself have a tendency to rely on the transactional to best explain supposedly wider, more principled analyses. Kennedy was essentially a moderate Republican whose enduring reputation was saved by an assassin’s bullet. Ukraine and her borders today are idealized and felt viscerally more than in 2014 because the incumbent President is in desperate need of it.





Mike said...

I hope some regular readers here are able to grok what was pointed out yesterday, but some seem unable to appreciate due to their disdain for Biden: U.S. oil production is higher now than it was when Biden took office. The price increases that aren't a result of the war in Ukraine are a result supply and demand, aka the free market.

Ed Cooper said...

When Democrats introduced an amendment requiring that the refined oil be sold in the U.S., it was killed by your precious Republicans, so the refined products would be sold to Asian markets. Keep believing your delusions, Mr. Trigoboff..

Ed Cooper said...

Mike didn't misspell anything ! That sign was visible at more than one TeaGoop Rally, spelled exactly as Mike reproduced it.

Ed Cooper said...

Thank you, Mike. Some folks just aren't happy unless they're trying to tear down President Biden. The Death Throes of conservatism and White Patriarchy are not pleasant to watch, as satisfying as that final rattle in the throat might be.

Low Dudgeon said...

If conservatism is indeed in its death throes, that means come 2023 we'll be re-interring the zombified remains of the old white-savior leftist "elite" in the knacker's yard. Hispanics are now 50/50 conservative voters, and as with with blacks and Asians that number is steadily climbing. Americans simply prefer individual reward and accountability to collectivist moralizing and passivity.

Mike said...

If Americans prefer individual reward and accountability, why are Trump and his co-conspirators still on the loose, and why is the Insurrection Party still a viable entity?

Michael Trigoboff said...

edc,

I’m not a Republican, particularly, and I would’ve opposed a prohibition against selling Keystone XL oil domestically.

Mc said...

The gop is the party of self-centeredness and greed.

Sacrifice for the good of the country? They couldn't even wear a mask to protect the lives of their neighbors.

Ed Cooper said...

Then you might as well be a Republican.

Malcolm said...

Right on, Rod! Thanks for pointing out those simple solutions, not only to our “high priced” gasoline, but this could be dxtrapolated to saving lives, health, and comfort to millions of refugees, from Ukraine and even Latin America.

I’d love to see some strong sanctions levied against the Uber rich in all areas, not just Russia. Imagine the problems we could address with all their ill gotten loot.

Malcolm said...

Pardon me if I've visited too many fake news sources, Michael T, but it’s my belief that the Keystone XL pipeline was designed to carry tar sands oil from Canada to Port Arthur, Texas, and then exported to the highest bidder. In other words, it wasn’t ever for USA consumption.

Ask any Canuck why these low grade petroleum products weren’t simply piped across Canada to the pacific ports. They’ll tell you it’s because they didn’t want that crummy oil to pollute their country, and it’s water supplies. Imagine the predicted, expected, and accepted pipeline ruptures' effect on the Ogalalla Aquifer, I believe the largest aquifer in the USA, stretching AT LEAST from south Dakota to West Texas, hundreds of feet thick, and generally composed of ultra porous sand and gravel alluvial deposits.

I knew farmers near Lubbock whose pumps were powered by 327 cubic inch Chevrolet V-8 engines, producing hundreds of gallons per minute of clean, pure, Ogalalla water.