"Turnabout is fair play."Donald Trump demanded mid-cycle redistricting of congressional districts.
Many red states complied. It was brutal. There was no pretense. They wanted more Republican seats; they said so openly.
Trump's partisan gerrymandering worked as planned in Tennessee. It would have worked well in Texas and North Carolina, too, except the blue wave was so big Democrats got elected even in districts gerrymandered to make that unlikely.
That brings us to Oregon. Republican U.S. Rep. Cliff Bentz did not make a peep of protest over the Republican gerrymanders. Why would he? He stood to benefit. They were intended to keep a Republican majority in the U.S. House, even if a substantial majority of American voters chose Democrats. He silently did what he has done for six years: consented to what Trump demands, even when it is immoral, undemocratic, hurts his district, and is hypocritical.
Bentz's congressional district exists due to the indulgence of Oregon’s Democratic majority. Democrats could have done a more partisan job of districting Oregon. Instead they created a nice Republican Eastern Oregon district, one where a MAGA Republican had an enormous advantage in a general election. It was a red version of the kind of blue district that Trump demanded be destroyed in states with Republican governance. Cliff Bentz sat pretty, watching Republicans be tough-minded and play to win while Oregon Democrats were burdened by a sense of fair play. What suckers.
Oregon Democrats can do to the 2nd Congressional District what Trump demanded of Republicans. Only unlike the tortured, illogical districts created in Tennessee, a perfectly reasonable new 2nd district could be drawn. It would be contiguous, it would have a logical community of interest, and it would be fair-minded and democratic. It would be a decidedly Democratic-leaning district in which a Democrat would likely win.
Redistricting could divide the current 2nd District by creating a Columbia River, I-84-centered district, joining the Port of Portland with the agricultural land that ships grain out of that port. Very sensible. The southern part of the district looks enormous on a map but has few people, and those people could be allocated to the remaining districts with minimal change to their partisan lean.
Oregon has Democratic voters to spare to accomplish this. Oregon’s 1st Congressional District, centered on west Portland and Beaverton, is a D+20 district. In 2025 there were 188,000 Democrats and only 82,000 Republicans. The 3rd District is D+24, with 216,000 Democrats and only 67,000 Republicans. Democrats “wasted” those votes. The new 2nd District would take substantial numbers of Democratic voters from Portland along the Columbia to create a Democratic-leaning district. Portland-area voters in the 3rd District would be reallocated to create six Democratic-leaning districts.
Democrats need not defend redistricting on predatory partisan grounds, the way Trump does. They can defend it on democratic-fairness grounds. Today the two Portland-area representatives need not worry about a general election. Cliff Bentz does not pretend to care about Democrats; he doesn't respond to our letters, he doesn't hold town meetings. He has an 81,000-voter Republican registration margin. Lopsided margins permit extreme partisan behavior for both parties. It is good government to have more competitive districts.
Let’s have six Democratic-leaning congressional districts where Republicans have a fighting chance if the Democratic incumbent does something stupid or corrupt. An unrepresentative Trump sycophant like Bentz would likely lose in any district of the six I propose, but Oregon voters do elect reasonable centrist Republicans: Mark Hatfield, John Dellenback, Vic Atiyeh, Tom McCall. A Republican like that could win even in a district with a Democratic lean.
Governor Tina Kotek and the Democratic legislature should act now. If Oregon Republicans object to mid-cycle redistricting, they should have spoken up when Trump was doing it. They didn't. Dividing the current 2nd District would end the “affirmative action” indulgence of a Bentz-friendly MAGA district and create fairer districts instead. It would give Republicans an incentive to nominate people who reflect the state’s median voter, if they choose to.
If Republicans nominate MAGA candidates who then lose all six districts, that is on them.

1 comment:
I completely agree. Giving these traitors a taste of their own medicine would be incredible.
Post a Comment