Maybe it’s a new era.
Maybe the midterm election results freed Oregon’s GOP congressman Cliff Bentz from dutiful, silent obedience to Trump.
Maybe Bentz realizes he has a duty to represent his constituents, not Trump. We can hope.
Bentz got just over 50 percent of the vote in this corner of his district. It didn’t matter. Big GOP majorities in the high desert counties east of the Cascades made the district safely red. His political risk presumably comes in the GOP primary, not the general election.
Bentz had excellent policy and political discipline. He left no room for a MAGA Trump-devotee, election-denier to claim he was more loyal to Trump than was Bentz. Bentz was 100-percent Trump-compliant.
When Trump tariffs hurt Oregon wheat farmers, Bentz did not object.
When Trump wanted the Epstein files locked up, Bentz went along, until Trump himself reversed course.
When Trump’s Big Beautiful Bill cut Medicaid, threatening coverage for tens of thousands of his constituents and pushing rural hospitals into even greater distress, Bentz went along.
Bentz stayed silent in the face of Trump crypto grift, pardon sales, and conflicts of interest.
I considered that silence morally wrong. It was also politically smart, if the goal is to keep a safe seat. Bentz gets little media attention, and he rarely faces citizens in settings he can’t control. What Republican voters know is that he wears the red jersey. That is enough to win the general.
Until now.
Bentz spoke up in protest of a Trump administration policy, a plan to sell public land without Congressional oversight and approval.
He said it to the Washington Examiner. The Examiner is owned by Colorado billionaire Philip Anschutz via the Clarity Media Group, and it plays the same role as Fox News and Rupert Murdoch’s other media properties: Republican, Trumpy, conservative, populist. The Examiner reached out to Bentz, and Bentz did something brand new for him. He said Congress -- he -- had not been told about the land sales. Then he made the case for the people who own that land: American citizens.I would want to make sure that this plan doesn’t exceed whatever the law allows the administration to do without congressional approval,” he said. “I’m not sure that this plan has been – I would hope that this plan has been developed with that limitation in mind.
You have to be extremely careful in how you dispose of it because it belongs to all of us and [you] better go through the proper hoops.
Here is the full article.
This new voice of independence is huge and unexpected. Formerly he would have said nothing. If pressed, he would have muttered something about Trump knowing best. He has a six-year record of enablement and validation of Trump. He accepted it when Trump ignored every checks-and-balances prerogative and power of Congress.
Maybe he is making a new political calculation. Republicans who put no daylight between themselves and Trump lost their elections this month, including Oregon's gubernatorial candidate Christine Drazan and state Senate candidate Brad Hicks. Neither dared voice a peep of opposition to Trump. It might have saved their campaigns had they done so. They didn't read the room. They wasted their time and their donors’ money, using it to sell the message that they were good soldiers in Trump’s army. How pointless. Such a waste.
Maybe Bentz noticed. Maybe Oregon Republicans are figuring out that Trump is bad news: dangerous, corrupt, lawless, and politically indefensible. Persuadable voters certainly realize it. Bentz seems to have woken up, and started acting like a representative, not a frightened sheep laying low in a flock. It's overdue, but encouraging to see.
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.]


3 comments:
Maybe this is a trend. Supporting a lame duck president whose policies are clearly against what America wants is now a liability. Other Republicans may follow. They see 2028 is coming up fast and if this trend is repeated, another third of the Senate may be lopped off. It seems that the American people are finally paying attention to what Trump has done and they don't like it. They voted that way. Trump will continue to insist that if he was on the ballot, the Republicans would have won. Trump never loses. Only other people do. I just got my copy of Time magazine with Trump on the cover saying he voted. The American people did too.
One robin doesn't harold Spring!
Well we now know Elon Musk is not MAGA, nor has he ever been MAGA. Just ask him, he will tell you. Wonder if Bentz is MAGA?
Post a Comment