Democrats form a circular firing squad.
I respect Democratic activists for their sincere integrity. They have political principles. They don't sell out.
Meanwhile, I scoff at the hypocrisy of Republicans who are maddeningly loyal to the GOP brand, but not to principles. Polls show that 95 percent of Republicans who voted for Reagan, Bush, and Romney now support Trump, who reversed much of what those presidential candidates stood for.
(I realize that Dick Cheney, Liz Cheney, and Adam Kinzinger got off the Trump bus. No generalization is perfect. A few Republicans told me they "held their noses" to vote for Trump. That makes my point. They support a candidate they have contempt for.)
Democrats are fractious. My TikTok feed sent me a video of a young woman telling other young Democrats to tell their parents NOT to support California Governor Gavin Newsom for president.
![]() |
We all have a personal responsibility at this point to convince our older, centrist Democrat family members that Gavin Newsom sucks before it’s too late. I’m sure I’m not the only person whose moms and aunts and uncles loves Gavin Newsom for the way he sticks it to Trump and tells it like it is. But we need to make it clear that he is the worst before they start donating to the presidential primary. So here is a non-exhaustive list of why this man cannot be the next president and if I miss anything, put it in the comments.
Gavin Newsom will not answer questions on whether or not he takes money from AIPAC.
He also says he is not pro-abolishing ICE.
He is actually cruel to homeless people who he sees only as obstacles on the way to his presidential ambitions.
He has publicly stated that he will fight tooth and nail against California’s billionaire tax ballot measure which would make sure that billionaires are paying their fair share.
He also told Ben Shapiro that he agreed with him and what’s happening in Palestine isn’t genocide.
He is obsessed with finding “common ground” with right wing extremists, platforming them on his podcast — people who have said things like that women are less than human.
Some of this is generational -- youthful passion meets parental moderation, an age-old story, so it might not portend a divided party. As the Beatles sang (Strawberry Fields, 1967) "It's nothing to get hung about." Possibly so.
But the video displays real fault lines in the Democratic response to the late-Trump era. Israel divides Democrats. Hamas and Israel have both done reprehensible things. Both are perpetrators; both are victims. Trump took a stand: Let Israel do anything it wants. Democrats want something more moderate and muddled, and no one will be happy
ICE divides Democrats. Some of its actions are reprehensible, defensible only by Trump's sycophants. But someone needs to enforce immigration laws or we have no immigration enforcement, and Americans rejected that. Democrats want something more muddled and, again, no one will be happy.
Tax policy divides Democrats. A No Kings sign saying "Tax Billionaires", or an AOC dress reading "Tax the Rich," has clarity. But in the reality of governing, tax surcharges on incomes have consequences. People and businesses can and do move to lower-tax places. Musk moved himself and his business operations from California to Texas. Financial firms are moving from New York to Miami. A home-grown local billionaire founder of Dutch Bros. coffee just announced he was moving the business from Grants Pass, Oregon to Arizona. Newsom says the billionaire tax would mean a net loss of revenue to California. Is he right? Maybe, but the burden of responsible governance requires that he consider that. A good slogan is not necessarily good government.
I envision a divided and politically unsatisfying presidential primary season as Democrats search for a unifying leader. I suspect there cannot be one. The Democratic Party is a collection of interest groups led by people with a mission. Abortion advocates tolerate no restriction on a fundamental right. Climate activists do not see natural gas as a transition fuel and a big improvement over coal; it is perpetuation of fossil fuels. Tax activists tolerate no limits because, after all, billionaires are morbidly rich. Immigration activists see the USA as the world's lifeboat, with a moral obligation to save refugees from violence and poverty.
The young woman in the video isn't arguing for self-interest. She wants a better world. She is sincere. Democratic interest group spokespeople are sincere. For the sincere, politics isn't a calculation of what is possible in a democracy. Right is right and wrong is wrong.
A California governor will carry a lot of baggage that will look extreme in Michigan, Georgia, and Pennsylvania. Gavin Newsom is probably at the left-progressive-woke edge of the spectrum of candidates who could possibly win a national election, and only under the most favorable of circumstances.
Yet he isn't good enough. It's my party and I'll cry if I want to.
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog by email go to Https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. The blog is free and always will be.]



















