Saturday, November 21, 2026

Redistrict Oregon. It is only fair.

"Turnabout is fair play."
Donald Trump demanded mid-cycle redistricting of congressional districts.


Many red states complied. It was brutal. There was no pretense. They wanted more Republican seats; they said so openly.

Democrats can redistrict because they want better, fairer congressional districts.

Trump's partisan gerrymandering worked as planned in Tennessee. It would have worked well in Texas and North Carolina, too, except the blue wave was so big Democrats got elected even in districts gerrymandered to make that unlikely.

That brings us to Oregon. Republican U.S. Rep. Cliff Bentz did not make a peep of protest over the Republican gerrymanders. Why would he? He stood to benefit. They were intended to keep a Republican majority in the U.S. House, even if a substantial majority of American voters chose Democrats. He silently did what he has done for six years: consented to what Trump demands, even when it is immoral, undemocratic, hurts his district, and is hypocritical.

Bentz's congressional district exists due to the indulgence of Oregon’s Democratic majority. Democrats could have done a more partisan job of districting Oregon. Instead they created a nice Republican Eastern Oregon district, one where a MAGA Republican had an enormous advantage in a general election. It was a red version of the kind of blue district that Trump demanded be destroyed in states with Republican governance. Cliff Bentz sat pretty, watching Republicans be tough-minded and play to win while Oregon Democrats were burdened by a sense of fair play. What suckers.

Oregon Democrats can do to the 2nd Congressional District what Trump demanded of Republicans. Only unlike the tortured, illogical districts created in Tennessee, a perfectly reasonable new 2nd district could be drawn. It would be contiguous, it would have a logical community of interest, and it would be fair-minded and democratic. It would be a decidedly Democratic-leaning district in which a Democrat would likely win.

Redistricting could divide the current 2nd District by creating a Columbia River, I-84-centered district, joining the Port of Portland with the agricultural land that ships grain out of that port. Very sensible. The southern part of the district looks enormous on a map but has few people, and those people could be allocated to the remaining districts with minimal change to their partisan lean.

Oregon has Democratic voters to spare to accomplish this. Oregon’s 1st Congressional District, centered on west Portland and Beaverton, is a D+20 district. In 2025 there were 188,000 Democrats and only 82,000 Republicans. The 3rd District is D+24, with 216,000 Democrats and only 67,000 Republicans. Democrats “wasted” those votes. The new 2nd District would take substantial numbers of Democratic voters from Portland along the Columbia to create a Democratic-leaning district. Portland-area voters in the 3rd District would be reallocated to create six Democratic-leaning districts.

Democrats need not defend redistricting on predatory partisan grounds, the way Trump does. They can defend it on democratic-fairness grounds. Today the two Portland-area representatives need not worry about a general election. Cliff Bentz does not pretend to care about Democrats; he doesn't respond to our letters, he doesn't hold town meetings. He has an 81,000-voter Republican registration margin. Lopsided margins permit extreme partisan behavior for both parties. It is good government to have more competitive districts.

Let’s have six Democratic-leaning congressional districts where Republicans have a fighting chance if the Democratic incumbent does something stupid or corrupt. An unrepresentative Trump sycophant like Bentz would likely lose in any district of the six I propose, but Oregon voters do elect reasonable centrist Republicans: Mark Hatfield, John Dellenback, Vic Atiyeh, Tom McCall. A Republican like that could win even in a district with a Democratic lean.

Governor Tina Kotek and the Democratic legislature should act now. If Oregon Republicans object to mid-cycle redistricting, they should have spoken up when Trump was doing it. They didn't. Dividing the current 2nd District would end the “affirmative action” indulgence of a Bentz-friendly MAGA district and create fairer districts instead. It would give Republicans an incentive to nominate people who reflect the state’s median voter, if they choose to.

If Republicans nominate MAGA candidates who then lose all six districts, that is on them.



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.] 



Friday, November 20, 2026

Guest Post: "I am a Christian who supports Donald Trump."

White Christians overwhelmingly support Donald Trump.

But not necessarily because they are Christian. It is because they are Republicans.

In the 2024 election the Public Religion Research Institute found that 85 percent of White evangelicals reported voting for Trump; 59 percent of White Catholics did so; 57 percent of White mainline Protestants did. But this is not so different from the proportions of White Christians who supported candidates Mitt Romney, George W. Bush and John McCain. For a half century Republicans have been the anti-abortion party. Democrats became the pro-choice party of feminists while becoming more secular, the party of college town sophisticates. The GOP emphasized tradition and resistance to diversity.

Trump delivered on abortion, having appointed three anti-abortion justices to the Supreme Court. He is an advocate for returning Christianity to a default place at the center of public life. He is a Christian cheerleader, even if he isn’t remotely Christian.

Linda Magstadt responded to my request for a guest post by a Christian who supports Trump. She doesn’t worship Trump, nor describe him as Christ-like. She doesn't defend his personal behavior. She doesn’t demand he obey the Ten Commandments, nor any of the Christian virtues expressed in the Sermon on the Mount. He doesn't need to be a good person. He can be everything Jesus condemned, because this is about politics. He isn’t perfect, she said, which is OK, because no one is.

I requested Linda Magstadt send me a brief biography. She sent me this: 

I am a conservative who believes in conserving resources, traditional values, history, finances, etc. As a pro-life conservative, I believe that the mother is also a victim of abortion and ache for both. I strive to live up to what I profess to believe and am forever grateful for God’s forgiveness and love.

Guest Post by Linda Magstadt

Thank you for your willingness to hear Christian thoughts about President Trump.

I am a Christian who supports Donald Trump.

In 2016 I voted for him and waited expectantly for him to “act more Presidential.” I am still waiting, but “acting” is what it usually is, a performance not rooted in core beliefs.

Donald Trump is authentic, New York brash, and at times full of himself. But he is consistent and we never have to guess what he is really thinking. And I support most of his policies: a strong border, safer streets, traditional values (ie, no transgender men in women’s sports), his respect for religious conviction (unless it is violent religious conviction.)

There is a difference between personal empathy and policy empathy. A hurting illegal immigrant elicits personal empathy but illegal immigrant crime, draining of resources for citizens of this country, women and children being hurt and sexually abused through unchecked border crossings, illegal drugs pouring in - all deal with policy empathy. (I have heard that there are still significant numbers of unaccounted for children). He has never changed from his conviction that Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon and while we (including me) want this conflict to end, I am reminded that earlier presidents were unwilling to deal with a problem that not only is a threat to America but a threat to the entire world.

When I wince at something he says, I remind myself that he scarcely sleeps, works tirelessly for what he believes in and does not partake in common relaxants such as alcohol. (I love thinking of his receiving a 3:00 am call and being completely sober.)

He has been shot at, impeached, prosecuted (unjustly in my opinion), hated, and still soldiers on. He is a remarkable person who, if future history is honest, will be remembered for his courage and decisiveness.

God uses imperfect people because there are no other kinds.

I recognize that some of the hate directed at him comes from the established political system because he is a threat to them and their power. But I cannot understand the hate that is directed at him by some citizens. I don’t know where it comes from and I don’t understand why. There have been presidents who I have disliked but never hated. If he were truly “Hitler,” a fascist (or a king), people would not be allowed to say such dangerous things.

At President Trump’s first State of the Union address he said that he wasn’t elected to protect the world; he was elected to protect the United States of America.

So take a deep breath America and chill just a bit. He is not your enemy.

 


[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.] 




Thursday, November 19, 2026

Did U.S. Rep. Cliff Bentz finally grow a spine?

Maybe it’s a new era.

Maybe the midterm election results freed Oregon’s GOP congressman Cliff Bentz from dutiful, silent obedience to Trump.

Maybe Bentz realizes he has a duty to represent his constituents, not Trump. We can hope.


Oregons 2nd Congressional District was drawn by Oregon Democrats to concentrate Republican voters. It wasn’t a punitive gerrymander. Rural Eastern Oregon voters wanted  a district with “their kind” of voter. They are spread across most of the land mass of Oregon, but there arent enough of them to fill a district, so the district picked up the necessary population by including my home county, Jackson County, with the small cities of Medford, Ashland, and Central Point.

Bentz got just over 50 percent of the vote in this corner of his district. It didn’t matter. Big GOP majorities in the high desert counties east of the Cascades made the district safely red. His political risk presumably comes in the GOP primary, not the general election.

Bentz had excellent policy and political discipline. He left no room for a MAGA Trump-devotee, election-denier to claim he was more loyal to Trump than was Bentz. Bentz was 100-percent Trump-compliant.

When Trump tariffs hurt Oregon wheat farmers, Bentz did not object.

When Trump wanted the Epstein files locked up, Bentz went along, until Trump himself reversed course.

When Trump’s Big Beautiful Bill cut Medicaid, threatening coverage for tens of thousands of his constituents and pushing rural hospitals into even greater distress, Bentz went along.

Bentz stayed silent in the face of Trump crypto grift, pardon sales, and conflicts of interest.

I considered that silence morally wrong. It was also politically smart, if the goal is to keep a safe seat. Bentz gets little media attention, and he rarely faces citizens in settings he can’t control. What Republican voters know is that he wears the red jersey. That is enough to win the general.

Until now.

Bentz spoke up in protest of a Trump administration policy, a plan to sell public land without Congressional oversight and approval.

He said it to the Washington Examiner. The Examiner is owned by Colorado billionaire Philip Anschutz via the Clarity Media Group, and it plays the same role as Fox News and Rupert Murdoch’s other media properties: Republican, Trumpy, conservative, populist. The Examiner reached out to Bentz, and Bentz did something brand new for him. He said Congress -- he -- had not been told about the land sales. Then he made the case for the people who own that land: American citizens.

I would want to make sure that this plan doesn’t exceed whatever the law allows the administration to do without congressional approval,” he said. “I’m not sure that this plan has been – I would hope that this plan has been developed with that limitation in mind.

You have to be extremely careful in how you dispose of it because it belongs to all of us and [you] better go through the proper hoops.

Here is the full article.

This new voice of independence is huge and unexpected. Formerly he would have said nothing. If pressed, he would have muttered something about Trump knowing best. He has a six-year record of enablement and validation of Trump. He accepted it when Trump ignored every checks-and-balances prerogative and power of Congress.

Maybe he is making a new political calculation. Republicans who put no daylight between themselves and Trump lost their elections this month, including Oregon's gubernatorial candidate Christine Drazan and state Senate candidate Brad Hicks. Neither dared voice a peep of opposition to Trump. It might have saved their campaigns had they done so. They didn't read the room. They wasted their time and their donors’ money, using it to sell the message that they were good soldiers in Trump’s army. How pointless. Such a waste.

Maybe Bentz noticed. Maybe Oregon Republicans are figuring out that Trump is bad news: dangerous, corrupt, lawless, and politically indefensible. Persuadable voters certainly realize it. Bentz seems to have woken up, and started acting like a representative, not a frightened sheep laying low in a flock. It's overdue, but encouraging to see.



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.] 



Wednesday, November 18, 2026

End the filibuster: Kevin Stine guest post.

The U.S. Senate is all about protecting the power of U.S. senators.

It is time for the Senate to be about doing what is good for Americans.

Members of the U.S. House of Representatives are members of a team. U.S. senators are principals. Individual senators have the power to stop the majority. They must be accommodated and coddled. It is so good to be a senator that they never want to leave.

The filibuster is one of their tools. So is the “blue slip.” Under this Judiciary Committee tradition of senatorial courtesy, a single home-state senator can keep a federal district court nominee from ever getting a hearing. Mississippi Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith used it in 2023 to block Scott Colom from the federal bench. This month Colom beat her for her Senate seat.

Senators can put a hold on a bill by refusing unanimous consent, which forces long, time-consuming procedures to advance it. A senator can demand that the clerk read an entire bill aloud.  On budget bills, senators can force vote after vote on amendments. Senators can hold the floor as long as they are physically able to keep speaking.

Senators can stop things.

The midterm blue wave raised voters’ expectations. Voters expect change. Between a presidential veto and Republican obstruction in the Senate, it is entirely possible that the story of the next two years will be “weak, feckless, do-nothing” Democrats. The public may not blame the obstructors. The public may decide that government by a bold, swashbuckling, rule-defying Republican president beats rule by a Congress that cannot get anything done.

Guest author Kevin Stine argues that the filibuster should go. Stine studied political science at Southern Oregon University. He has been elected four times to the Medford City Council and was a delegate to the Democratic National Convention in 2016, 2020 and 2024. He has run four marathons, served on three submarine deployments, and loves to dive into voting precinct reports. All views are his own. He can be reached at info@kevinstine.com.

Guest Post by Kevin Stine

On January 3, 2027, the 120th Congress will come to order. Democrats will control the Senate, likely with 56 members in their caucus. On that day, Senate Democrats should end the legislative filibuster.

The legislative filibuster is an enormous barrier to real progress for the American people. The current rule requires 60 votes for cloture, which limits debate and moves a bill toward a final vote. After that, a simple majority passes it.

The filibuster may serve a purpose in theory. In practice, the minority party uses it to stop the majority from passing bills. Ideas with broad public support either never get past cloture or are watered down until they no longer fix the problem they were meant to fix.

Some say majority rule is the problem. I would argue that a minority with veto power over legislation is the bigger one. Simple majorities should be able to pass bills. If the filibuster were far more limited, or senators more willing to compromise, it would be a different story. That’s not where we are.

The Senate moves at a glacial pace, even on minor votes. Recent changes, though, have let nominations move through when the outcome is already known, instead of wasting days of floor time.

--  In 2013, under President Obama, Majority Leader Harry Reid faced unprecedented obstruction and used his majority to end the filibuster for executive branch and judicial nominations, except for the Supreme Court.
--  In 2017, Mitch McConnell ended the filibuster for Supreme Court nominees to confirm Neil Gorsuch.
--  In 2019, McConnell cut the time between cloture and a final vote from 30 hours to 2 hours for most nominees.
--  In 2025, Majority Leader John Thune began confirming sub-cabinet nominees in batches, so executive appointments no longer each take up days of floor time.

These are efficient measures that make the Senate work. The minority party of the moment cried foul at each one. But every time the Senate has changed hands, the new majority has kept the changes and enjoyed the results. No one has ever brought the old time-wasting procedures back.

In January, it will be time to go further so the Senate can get its work done. Democrats will have the chance to pass the legislation they have talked about for my entire adult life and send it to President Trump. If he vetoes it, make him do it. The people deserve to know what the Democratic Party is willing to pass. Ending the legislative filibuster is the only path to real progress.



 [Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.] 


 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

What the heck, call it "Trumpcare."

Donald Trump wants a great legacy. How about we give him one:

                             Trumpcare.

I think it is a real possibility, if Democrats can stand the idea of Trump taking credit for something they consider their idea. 


The mechanism for bipartisan support for universal healthcare for American citizens has just been put into place. The mechanism is Trump's desire for a grand legacy combined with a new majority of Democrats who understand they were elected with a mandate for bold change.

Trump has no ideology. He doesn’t care about health policy. He cares about money and glory. Trump is in a get-it-done mindset. He does not care about GOP policy tradition, or about GOP legislators with long records of condemning socialized medicine and Obamacare. He doesn’t feel a need to be consistent. Showing the world he abandons allies and past policy to do something new and bold is a plus for Trump.

“Trumpcare,” spoken of for decades, for centuries, as enduring as Social Security; that is a legacy. And he stole the credit from Democrats, also a plus. He will get his face on coins, like FDR and Jefferson. The country will praise his name.

New up-and-coming Democrats are on board. 

--- Abdul El-Sayed, Michigan Senator-elect, said:

Donald, if you’re watching, we can put your name on it. . . So if he wants to call it Trumpcare, I’m game.

--- Michigan Senator Elissa Slotkin said:

If slapping Trump’s name on it and putting it in gold letters would get it through, then hell yes I’m for it.

--- James Talarico, Texas Senator-elect, told Democrats the way to make progress was to work with Trump:

The American people cannot wait two years for change. So we must work with President Trump. If President Trump wants the same plaques and portraits and busts as LBJ, we can help make that a reality.

This only works if there are liberal tears. Some Democratic interest groups will need to complain loudly. They will do so.

---  Trumpcare will be for U.S. citizens only. That will be a selling point for the nativist wing of the GOP electorate.

--- Trumpcare will not include abortion services. That is necessary to keep the anti-abortion crowd on board. Some Democrats will scream bloody murder. Good. Democrats can live with this. Planned Parenthood will do what needs to be done.

--- Trumpcare won’t cover gender-transition care. This, too, will generate loud complaints. Liberal tears are the price of success.

--- Trump will brag that he got done what Bernie Sanders and Barack Obama and Joe Biden only dreamed about. Look how great I am! Let him brag. Agree with him. Trump will have done something huge: He will have delivered Republican votes. GOP legislators spent over a decade doing Trump’s bidding when they disliked what he was doing (tariffs, the Iran war) and when he was an embarrassment (the tweets, the corruption). Trump created a constituency habituated to obedience and enablement. Democrats found that contemptible. Now they can use it.

Trumpcare serves multiple goals. It broadens access to health care. It separates health care from employment, freeing up the labor market. It lowers overall health care costs by reducing insurance friction. All good things.

It also meets a bipartisan political imperative: affordability. It is income redistribution in light disguise. It socializes a cost, moving it to taxpayers and paying for it with a progressive tax.

Henry of Navarre was a Protestant, and King of France in name, but Catholic Paris objected. So he converted to Catholicism. “Paris is worth a Mass,” he supposedly said. It was smart: Get the big thing.

If Democrats need to call it Trumpcare and provide a huge victory for Trump to claim, do it. It’s worth it. It's the big thing.



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.] 



Monday, November 16, 2026

How to pay for Social Security

The USA made a promise:

Put money into Social Security while you work. Retire and withdraw money roughly proportional to your deposits.
The promise no longer pencils out.

Everybody knows the problem. There are solutions, but they are unpopular. The benefit of fiscal solvency is abstract; the solutions are concrete and painful. 

Yesterday I posited that I and others in my situation would need to pay more in taxes. That will be one approach. Erich Almasy, in today's guest post, suggests another: The USA is asset-rich and we should monetize those assets. The country is underutilizing some of them (e.g. public lands in the West) and creating enormous wealth with other assets and discoveries that we are treating as free public goods. Almasy's post looks at the opportunity and rewards, a step in finding a solution. The furious opposition would come as soon as a person, business, or public-interest group sees how it would affect them. My grazing rights! No! Not that!

In retirement, Erich Almasy and his wife Cynthia Blanton, both college classmates, live in the Mexican city of San Miguel de Allende.

Guest Post by Erich Almasy


Cynthia Blanton and Erich Almasy in 1996, about eight years after their story

In a recent post, commenters noted the size of the Social Security liability and the expected default of its retirement trust fund in late 2032 if current revenue and expenses continue as they are. The long-term Social Security and Medicare shortfalls (kept off the government’s books) dwarf even the annual budget deficit, and both parties’ reluctance to address them directly causes chronic concern among fiscal experts and financial markets.

When my wife and I had our modest consulting firm during the 1980s, we confronted this situation on a micro-scale. One client was a small Caribbean country with a population of about 45,000, our first venture into geopolitics.

 

We interviewed government officials and businesspeople. Like many in the Caribbean, the country had been, until recently, a British colony with a single source of income: sugar. After independence, small manufacturing and tourism began, but sugar remained dominant, and that was a serious problem because Brazil was selling sugar for less than this country could produce it. We uncovered evidence that the country’s National Bank had been using the Social Security payments to cover the “overdraft” (a quaint British banking term for a deficit) in the national budget. Not only was the country’s own national retirement system, called its Social Security Scheme, breaking, but so was the country. Sound familiar? Only in this country’s case, if the IMF and World Bank found out, all of their loans and development plans would be in serious jeopardy.

Prior consultants had examined the problem. Their reports talked about tourism and local manufacturing but never explained how to get out from under the sugar albatross. The sugar fields and refinery were owned by the National Sugar Company, which employed most of the workforce, paid their wages, and withheld their Social Security Scheme deposits. The National Bank then borrowed to lend to the National Sugar Company to pay those wages, and so on, in a never-ending circle. It was a national Ponzi scheme, only with good intentions. Apparently, we were the first outsiders to discover the problem, and during our final presentation to the Prime Minister and his Cabinet, we uncorked a shocker.

We began, as usual, with references to future opportunities, watched their eyes glaze over, and then said, “But none of this matters, because you’re broke!” That got their attention. We then explained the borrowing-and-deficit cycle in simple but devastating terms. A stricken audience awaited the sword of Damocles until we said, “There is a solution.”

Before independence, largely White plantation owners had managed all the sugar lands (roughly 80 percent of the arable surface). They couldn’t survive on the margins from selling sugar below world prices, so they offered their holdings to the government en masse, and in 1975 the government took them over. A Supreme Court ruling said the country had to pay for the lands. That created an opportunity, since the land was carried on the books at a small value.

Our solution was to revalue the land asset and essentially offset it against the Social Security deficit liability. The asset would pay a small “rent,” enough to cover any Social Security outlays and repay the previous owners. Luckily, the population was young and still far from retirement. Out from under the heretofore insoluble deficit, the government could get back on an even keel, moving sugar workers to new professions and borrowing from international lenders. As it turned out, the country became a leading supplier of second passports and a giant port for cruise ships.

Okay, so why is any of this relevant to the situation the United States faces? First, the borrowing from Peter to pay Paul is quite similar. Our Social Security Trust Fund is an accounting joke, since the money goes right into the general fund in exchange for Treasury IOUs, and the general fund must cover those IOUs as payments come due. Second, the United States has huge, underutilized assets. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) of the Department of the Interior controls 245 million surface acres (about 11 percent of the U.S. landmass) and 700 million acres of subsurface mineral rights. The Department of Agriculture’s Forest Service controls 193 million acres (about 9 percent of our landmass), mostly forest land. Altogether, the federal government is estimated to own 28 percent of all U.S. land, or about 640 million acres. Traditionally (and because of lobbying and special interests), the grazing, mineral, and oil rights to these lands have been significantly underpriced. Imagine if we charged market rates! Better yet, since so much of this land is blustery, parched desert, imagine building wind and solar farms to harvest its wind and sun.

And it doesn’t stop there. Since 1934, the FCC has controlled the broadcasting spectrum, which, again, was handed to broadcasters free of charge in exchange for serving the public interest, a mandate now largely abandoned. Perhaps greatest of all is the government giveaway of the taxpayer-funded research behind semiconductors and microprocessors, the Internet, Google’s page-ranking algorithm, GPS, CRISPR gene-editing, MRI, smartphones, and mRNA vaccines. We are not really broke; we are just stupid! If we moved America’s assets into the Social Security Trust Fund and had a non-partisan board set proper prices, we could all live happily ever after. 

Oh, and make sure there is no upper limit to the Social Security tax, just as there is none for Medicare.



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.] 



Sunday, November 15, 2026

Easy Sunday: Maybe we need a great equalizing event.

"Why is everybody always picking on me?"
         The Coasters, 1959

Maybe I need to pay more in taxes.

I won't like it.

Like it or not, we are all in this together. The country needs to work for pretty much everyone. Otherwise, discord.

There is a great deal more inequality in America than there was in the country I grew up in. I was born in 1949, at the front end of the baby boom. There was a giant middle class, and White people could enter it if they had a full-time job. People with jobs could own a home. There was income inequality, of course, but people with professional jobs did not live conspicuously better than people who worked at the lumber mills. Better, yes. They drove Cadillacs instead of Chevys and had two-bathroom homes instead of one, but psychologically they were in the same place: middle-class Americans.

Children of millworkers could go to college, get a professional job, and buy a Cadillac.

Things are different now, and not in a good way for our country. It shows up in bad ways:

-- We are in a new gilded age of very wealthy people who hold both economic and political power.

-- Young people find the elevators of upward social mobility very expensive. Measured against the minimum-wage jobs available to students, my local regional state university, Southern Oregon University, is as expensive as the most expensive private colleges in America were in 1967.

-- The indicia of a middle-class life -- a home, access to health care, a reliable car, children, a 40-hour workweek, a comfortable-enough retirement at 65 -- are a stretch. Or out of reach.

The result is widespread resentment and frustration. People feel the world is stacked against them, rigged to benefit someone else. Christians think they are picked on. White people think they are picked on by DEI. Blacks, Hispanics, Muslims, and Asians think they are picked on. Women feel picked on. LGBTQ people feel picked on. Cisgender heterosexuals feel picked on. Immigrants and second-generation Americans feel picked on. Poor people feel picked on. Prosperous people feel picked on. Even billionaires feel picked on.

JFK’s 1961 inaugural address spoke of a shared burden to survive and thrive as a country -- ask what you can do for your country. Today that seems dated and naive. Don’t be a sap. New York tycoon and candidate Donald Trump bragged that he didn’t pay taxes. “That makes me smart.” He got elected in 2016 after saying that.

I grew up in the shadow of the total mobilization of a world war. In WWII businesses owned by rich old men had been protected by young men drafted into the military and by civilians in war factories. Those soldiers had earned a place at the table. A very progressive tax structure reflected a sense that every part of the society owed something to all the others.

Billionaires don’t want to share and redistribute their wealth. Nor do millionaires. They feel picked on. Look out for number one. 

Something has got to change. A nuclear war would push reset. Less disruptive would be an attack on the power grid. A month without electricity, food, water, or health care would remind comfortable people who the essential people are. A pandemic as contagious as measles and as deadly as Ebola would do it, too. We would all need the cooperation of each other.



Maybe the November 3 election is a sign the tide is turning. Right-wing populism built on resentments of race, ethnicity, and gender may be giving way to a populism built on disgust over self-serving corruption at the top and over its effect on affordability.. We might not need a cataclysm. Maybe political change can fix things. The Progressive Era followed the Gilded Age. We didn't need a revolution.

Something fundamental needs to change in how income is distributed. 

It wouldn't kill wealthy people to pay more in taxes. But they won't like it and will resist it.



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.]