Friday, June 23, 2023

Saudi golf: Sand dunes to sand traps.

Saudi Arabia has used its oil and its money to help -- and torment -- the U.S.

Saudi Arabia is the world's "swing producer" of oil. They have oil to sell, but don't need to sell all they can produce. By raising or lowering production they manage the quantity of oil and therefore its price.

A month ago they were in the news when they announced they will cut production beginning in July. The price of oil went up. Gasoline prices went up. That affects inflation and inflation consciousness. They just made things harder for Biden. Their $2 billion investment in Jared Kushner's brand new hedge fund was a goodwill gesture with Trump. Last week the PGA announced a planned merger with LIV, the new Saudi professional golf association. Some of the tournaments are at Trump properties.

Jack Mullen lives in Washington, D.C. He closely follows both politics and sports and he reads history. The news of the PGA/LIV merger combined all these interests.

Jack Mullen and Jennifer Angelo

Guest Post by Jack Mullen

The Arabian Peninsula ended the 19th Century with feuding Bedouin tribes fighting each other. Outside the peninsula, no one cared. European countries, saved by the 1815 Congress of Vienna, ended the 19th Century with their empires crumbling, destined for a tumultuous 20th century. Meanwhile, the U.S. entered the new century extending its Manifest Destiny’s reach by plucking pieces of the weak Spanish Empire from the Caribbean to the Philippines. 

Abd al-Azziz al Saud, with his band of 30 brothers, after collaborating with various rivals, declared victory in 1902. Among the previous rivals that merged with Emir al-Azziz, the most notable was a Bedouin faction that consisted of Wahhabi Islamic purists, the Ikhwans. Abd al-Azziz steadily increased his power to the point that, in 1932, he declared himself King of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. A year later, in 1933, oil was discovered in Saudi Arabia. Amid the Depression and the New Deal, Roosevelt and his Administration found time to establish diplomatic relations with them.

Abd al Azziz de Saud quickly requested that U.S. petroleum companies  help develop Saudi oil resources. Much to the displeasure to the House of Saud’s Wahhabi faction, the Saudi government and Standard Oil of California established ARAMCO, the Arab American Oil Company.

Abd al-Azziz de Saud and Roosevelt formed a long-distance mutual admiration society. FDR left Yalta Conference February 11, 1945, and made a bee-line to the America’s wartime embassy, the U.S.S. Quincy, docked in the Suez Canal. FDR met with the aging Saudi monarch on the Quincy’s top deck. In deference the King’s strong Islamic beliefs, FDR wisely ditched his cigarettes and cigarette holder on the Quincy’s elevator. The two old men formed a secret alliance. The U.S. needed Saudi oil for WWII. The Saudis wanted protection from neighboring enemies. In exchange for Saudi oil, the U.S. would provide the Saudis with military assistance.

Saudi oil helped the Allied war effort, as well as the U.S. auto industry in the booming post-war years. Military bases in Saudi Arabia benefited House of Saud greatly, but at a long-term cost to the U.S. As the world dependence in oil grew, so did the entanglement of Saudi and American oil families, including a Texas oil family, the Bushes. By the end of the 20th century, the Saudis and the Bush families were large contributors to the Carlyle Investment Group. Ex-President George Herbert Walker Bush was on the Carlyle Board of Directors from 1998-2003, joining just two years after his Presidency.

As President, George HW Bush thought he was saving Saudi oil fields when the U.S. military quickly removed the invading Iraqi army from Kuwait. Maybe he did save Saudi oil fields, although Saddam claims he received the tacit U.S. approval from Ambassador April Glaspie to invade and stop at Kuwait. The American invasion of Kuwait did not sit well with the Wahhabis, nor with the most prominent Wahhabi, the Saudi, Osama bin Laden.

Then, the 9/11 attacks. We know 15 of the 19 hijackers on 9/11 were Saudi nationals.

A group of hawkish conservatives including Paul Wolfowitz, Richard Perle and Donald Rumsfeld, penned a letter in 1998 to President Clinton, urging him to remove Saddam Hussein and his regime from Iraq. Clinton rejected the idea. George W. Bush became President in 2001. His Vice President and the Secretaries of Defense and State liked the idea of removing Saddam Hussein’s regime from Iraq. The opportunity to go after Saddam gained traction soon after 9/11. Using the buzzword "terrorist," which the perpetrators of 9/11 most assuredly were, the administration made the case that there was no greater terrorist on the world stage than Saddam Hussein, a madman in possession of weapons of mass destruction. The  Neocons in the Bush Administration pulled a bait and switch, changing the focus from the Saudi terrorists to Saddam Hussein, who, as we know, did not possess weapons of mass destruction.

In an attempt to offset Saudi Arabia’s dismal human rights record, the Saudi Government set up a successful Public Investment Fund (PIF) in 1971. Quietly, PIF money spread around the world. Uber received $3.2 billion PIF funds.

The Saudi sovereign wealth fund found a warm welcome in the sporting world, especially soccer. Golf is another story. Saudi Arabia’s newly established golf tour, LIV, challenged the PGA’s anti-trust exemption by signing 11 PGA golfers to expensive contracts. Phil Mickelson’s $200 million signing bonus sent shock waves through the golf world. Victims of 9/11 objected to Saudi money being tossed at wealthy golfers. PGA commissioner Jay Monahan, invoking memories of 9/11, said the PGA would never deal with the new Saudi league.

Golf is a conservative sport with a hallowed tradition. LIV decided to shake up golf. LIV tournaments are set up to attract a different, younger crowd. Team-play, employed by colleges and high schools, is a big part of LIV tournaments, as is loud music. Loud music seems popular at football and basketball games, why not golf?

After a year of LIV golf, Monahan stunned the golf world by meeting secretly with Saudi’s PIF head, Yassir Al-Rumayann, in Vienna. Monahan came out of that meeting and announced of a PGA-LIV merger.

The PGA’s commercial and business rights will now be owned by a new for-profit entity owned by LIV (PGA is a non-profit organization). Mickelson and other LIV players who had challenged the PGA’s anti-trust exemption, dropped their lawsuits. They also cropped suits against LIV for violating PGA players’ contracts. The PGA had been losing money. The Saudis knew this. The cost of all the lawsuits put Monahan in a corner. He cried uncle. The Saudis now play a prominent part in pro golf. Golf fans can now take Uber to PGA matches, thanks to the Saudi Sovereign Wealth Fund.

Victims of 9/11 are stunned. Monahan prepared himself for being a called a hypocrite. Two different Senate Committees, including Ron Wyden’s Finance Committee, are investigating the merger. So is the U.S. Department of Justice. Monahan has ended up hospitalized with some undisclosed illness.

Who knew what placid, old golf could do to Saudi-U.S. relations!



[Note: For daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. The blog is free and always will be.] 



5 comments:

Mike Steely said...

When Bush invaded Iraq instead of Saudi Arabia after 9/11, a story circulated that the military misadventure’s name was going to be Operation Iraqi Liberation, or OIL for short, but the administration decided that was too cynical even for Bush so they changed the name to Operation Iraqi Freedom (remember ‘freedom fries?). What makes the story more than a rumor is that Ari Fleischer referred to Operation Iraqi Liberation in a press release that’s now part of the National Archives.

Yes folks, only God knows how many lives and dollars have been squandered in pursuit of the fossil fuels that are themselves killing us.

Rick Millward said...

It's golf...a ridiculous sport designed to drive men insane, though one might be already if they take it up. The only thing dumber than playing it is watching it.

All professional sports are about money. What will we do when the Saudis set their sights on the NFL or (my lord!!) or...or....MLB?

Buckle up!

Phil Arnold said...

The most interesting and informative article on the internet this morning. Thank you, Jack Mullen and Peter, too.

Michael Trigoboff said...

What apparently nobody remembers except me, is that after the first Gulf War, inspectors from the IAEA went into Iraq and discovered a secret installation of calutrons (a primitive version of a cyclotron) that were being used to produce weapons grade uranium 235. This was a technique that the United States had used at the beginning of the Manhattan Project, but abandoned because it was considered to be too slow.

Starting around 2000, Saddam Hussein started interfering with the IAEA inspectors, creating the impression that he was pursuing nuclear weapons again. Given his history of previous pursuits, there was good reason to believe it.

After we conquered Iraq, it turned out that he was not actually pursuing nuclear weapons, but just trying to create the impression that he was, in an attempt to intimidate his neighbors. But we know that with hindsight. The possibility looked quite threatening in the post 9/11 period, given the knowledge that was available to us at the time.

M2inFLA said...

RE: It's golf...a ridiculous sport designed to drive men insane.

Not really. Not all of us.

My wife, son, and I played golf on and off as a family sport when we lived in Beaverton. That was before our son got active in middle school and high school sports - soccer and lacrosse. In HS he did well, and was a player on teams that became Oregon state champions in Division III during that first 2000 decade.

Though he was recruited by colleges to play lacrosse, he said no, as he knew inside that he'd never make a career of it.

When we made Florida our home in 2019, we decided on a golf community. Not any golf community, but the largest in the US. There are over 700 holes of golf we can play - that's more than 60 courses we can play, that are a golf cart drive away from our home. Nancy Lopez once lived here and has a course named for her, and Arnold Palmer designed another championship course here. Most of the courses are 9 hole "executive" courses that are free for us to play at. Only the championship courses cost residents a fee.

Are we insane? No more so than the folks who play tennis, pickleball, pool volleyball, ride bikes, or participate in other activities during their retirement years here.

For me, my wife and our fellow golfing friends, it is camaraderie while we play and socialize at the watering hole after the game. I play 4 times a week; others play less, and some people even play everyday. Along with some of the other sports activities I just mentioned. There are also many, many clubs for those who are into non-sports activities.

We get fresh air, and some exercise with golf and our other activities.

My doctor says leading an active life during our senior years can only help our health.

Our doctor has never said it might cause us to go insane.

The current political rhetoric is more likely to do that.