Sunday, May 24, 2020

The masks come off

Click: No mask for me


Body Language.


Polls say Americans are still concerned about the virus. 


I don't believe the polls. People are restless and tired of the shutdown. 

They are going back to "normal" and taking their chances.


Fivethirtyeight.com reports that for six weeks Americans have shared the same view on the virus, with 70% concerned about it, 30% not very concerned.

I don't doubt it is what they tell pollsters, but it isn't how they behave. In stores that don't actively enforce distancing rules, most shoppers go mask-less now. That isn't just stores selling farm and ranch gear where maskless faces have always been the rule.  It is grocery stores with older, upscale customers. 

The streets are busy again. My wife got her hair done.
 
CLICK: .fivethirtyeight.com/
Americans have lost patience, and are behaving like they don't think they will get the virus, and if they do they won't get too sick. The freeway accident. We understand the syndrome.

This is an accident on the freeway. We are driving in snowy conditions. Still, we have to get to work or get home. The freeway is the only practical way to travel, so we drive on it. What else???

Snow causes temporary closure of freeway
Going along we notice freeway traffic slows for congestion at an accident scene, and as we creep by we see tire tracks that show a car spun out, rolled over, and hit a light pole, the car totaled, the passenger area crushed. Ugly. Two ambulances are on the scene. For the next mile or two traffic slows to safer speeds, but then one starts getting passed by 4-wheel-drive pickup trucks, then regular cars, then more cars, and soon everyone is driving back at freeway speeds, or nearly so, despite the snow. Even nervous drivers, still shaken by the accident, are forced to speed up somewhat stay with the flow of traffic.

That is what's happening.

Americans are getting conflicting messages. Some official reports say that it is "a dusting of light snow," i.e. that the virus is real, and just a worse version of typical wintry weather. You don't close the freeways for three months for that. Other reports are saying "Breaking News! Mayhem of the freeways."  

President Trump is saying a version of both, reading aloud statistics and reports and having third party experts saying the virus is dangerous, the worst ever. We know he doesn't mean it. It is "teleprompter Trump" the Trump personae who occasionally says--reading deadpan-- what his job requires him to say. The real Trump is when he talks extemporaneously in his natural language, and fights with reporters and refuses to wear a mask. His actual message is that the virus is just typical winter weather, the freeways should be open, drive carefully if you really want to, but drive.

What message do people actually get and put into practice? The message with their own eyes, that hardly anybody gets the virus and dies. 

Most people do not live in or near New York City. People understand New York to be a special case, a contrast to themselves. Most people see the virus as something that happens to other people far away, people with a special case of working in certain factories, or people with pre-existing problems they themselves do not have. After a short period of uncertainty, people have settled into considering it a statistical risk, like any time they get into a car. Sure, some people need to be especially careful and should protect themselves, but otherwise, open up the freeways, go with the flow of traffic, and get back to normal.

Democrats and mainstream media have been telling a story of mayhem on the freeways. It isn't what most Americans see, and even if they do see it, it isn't how Americans want to live. This could be good news for Trump, but not necessarily. 

Democrats don't need to say they were wrong. No need to look sad about success. They could declare victory. But the victory may be temporary. In my community, with masks off, the virus number suddenly spiked, from essentially no new cases for several weeks, to twelve. Democrats need to avoid being the killjoy party. Of course, Republicans need to avoid being the lots of people die party.










7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Affluent Americans are willing to risk getting COVID19 from hair stylists who are going to work sick, since the working poor stylists don't get paid sick leave or medical insurance. High price for a cheap haircut.

140 clients exposed to COVID19 at a Missouri Great Clips, where 2 stylists tested positive. One worked for 8 days with COVID symptoms.
https://www.nydailynews.com/coronavirus/ny-coronavirus-great-clips-hair-stylist-missouri-20200524-zp2jjzzenvg4fmblbdtm7ibcom-story.html

John C said...

There's an interesting parallel to something that happened 40 years ago that I'm sure social psychologists can put a name to. I was living in Portland at the time and Mt. St. Helens was spewing ash and the dome in the crater was growing as there were tremors. People living in or near the danger zone were ordered to evacuate. A crusty old guy named Harry Truman refused. Others did leave but after weeks of it not getting worse, the residents protested so loudly that their rights were being violated, that the government relented let them go back. I thought they were crazy. The daily reports were clear it was only a matter of when and not if it was going to blow. Fifty-seven people, along with Harry Truman perished. A lot more were lucky and dodged a bullet. The difference back then of course is people could weigh the risks to themselves, make a choice, and face the consequences. This is different from today because mask-wearing isn't just about the individual's choice for him or herself. It's about caring for and protecting others. But many who oppose masks are convinced that individual rights trump the rights of society. in this view, selfish hyper-individualism is seen as not only an entitlement, but the best way to live one's life. Any who question this "doctrine" are vilified. Little do some of anti-maskers consider that their "right" to dissent was paid for by people who sacrificed themselves to preserve that right. Perhaps they might consider a much smaller sacrifice for others.

Andy Seles said...

"selfish hyper-individualism" it is, indeed, that most cherished of American "values" recently carried to the extreme of having the right to cry "fire" in a crowded theater.

Never underestimate peer pressure. Adults are not much better than teenagers in that regard, especially in an age of "bigger, better, faster, more." I predict a second outbreak that will parallel the first...and, don't forget, Mr. Covid mutates.

My wife and I are elderly and suffer from autoimmune diseases; we will be married to our PPE and social distancing for a long time. Even then we know we are reducing the odds, not getting a guarantee.



Andy Seles

Ralph Bowman said...

Mask refuseniks , I am burning my mask for freedom!

When I was a kid during the war you had to close your blackout curtains because the enemy could see where to drop a bomb. When a house had a yellow quarantine sticker on the door, no one went out, no one came in. When you heard a siren you pulled to the right. These chest pounding freedom screamers act like high school kiddies ( with guns.) They need a slap from their Mama. Or a ear twist from Their Daddy. One atomic bomb and this country would fold like a doll house. No cooperation, every man for himself. Ultimate anarchy in the name of Democratic freedom.. “I won’t grow up, never grow up, not me, not I “

Anonymous said...

Have you ever considered that the coronavirus was intentionally introduced into America in order to disrupt our society? It's destroyed the economy, and made everyone a hermit in their homes. Just what America's communist enemies wanted. Four months ago, the virus was unknown, and people didn't know what to expect. Much more information is available now, and most people understand that this new virus is no more dangerous than the common seasonal flu on-steroids. 99% of the population won't be affected, and it's ridiculous to close-down the economy for the 1% that are at risk. They can self-quarantine is they need to. For the rest of the population, it's time to get back to business. The best defense is a herd-immunity. I'm not afraid, Are you?

Ralph Bowman said...

Gee Anonymous brilliant scientific insights. What do you own that you bought from the Communists? You love your granddaddy ? You love your neighbors? Rip off that mask and LIVE!

John C said...

Dear Anonymous
apart from your conspiracy question, I believe you confirmed my point about the anti-maskers – that it’s up to each person to take risks. But here’s a question for all who think like that. I have a skydiving exclusion to my life insurance policy. It states that my beneficiaries will not get a payout if I die from skydiving. Would you be willing to take such an exclusion if you choose to not follow COVID safety protocols? Let’s take it a bit further. Oregon has a right to die law. Would you be willing to waive your right to life-saving healthcare if you get the virus and need expert medical help? If you think about it, you’re asking others in your shared risk pool to pick up the tab for your medical costs and you are asking medical workers to put themselves at risk to care for you because you choose to live a riskier life.

We are not as independent as we think. something to think about.