"Peter, I know the importance of the hook and how you use rock songs to draw people into your posts. The problem is when too many commenters respond to the hook rather than the message."
Comment from a college classmate
The title of this blog post is from Helen Reddy's feminist anthem, "I Am Woman."
![]() |
| Helen Reddy |
And I've been down there on the floorNo one's ever gonna keep me down againWhoa, yes, I am wiseBut it's wisdom born of painYes, I've paid the priceBut look how much I gainedIf I have to, I can do anythingI am strong (strong)I am invincible (invincible)I am woman (ooh)
She belts out the song. She is assertive and proud. Feminine is a good thing, a strong thing. I am male, but I feel entirely entitled to express what kind of feminism I like. I like Helen Reddy's kind. Confident. Not the #MeToo kind, where women complain of long-past injuries where they got injured but didn't say anything. I like the in-your-face, I-demand-respect-now kind.
I suggested that readers send me appropriate song lyrics for the Canada-USA relationship. The popular music world is full of breakup songs. Canada is publicly breaking up with the USA, voiced in the speech in Davos by Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney.
I wanted people to notice that Carney wasn't longing for the good old days and getting back together. Readers needed to find lyrics where the singer initiated the breakup because the former sweetheart became violent toward her and others. He begun hanging out with a bad crowd. He justified taking things from others. She wasn't that kind of girl and would not stand for it.
Notice that Carney didn't say that the USA suddenly "went bad" under Trump. He said the USA had always been a bully, that the USA had always felt entitled to demand that the world bow to its interests. The USA has been a self-righteous hypocrite from the moment it survived World War II with its industry and military intact. The difference now is that the selfishness is celebrated by Trump, not denied under the guise of being a benevolent policeman. Carney said that Trump exposes the truth about the relationship. The strong do as they will; the weak suffer as they must.
Probably no American politician can dare say what Carney said. It would be insulting America, and we don't want to hear an unpleasant truth. Americans understand our nation to be the shining beacon of truth, justice, and international law. We are Ronald Reagan's virtuous city on the hill. Possibly that self-image made the U.S. a better, less hypocritical, great power than we would otherwise have been. We wanted to live up to the hype.
Carney admitted that the Pax Americana of the past 80 years has had some benefits for Canada. That is why Canada could accept the relationship for so long.
Reader comments suggest that people engaged with Carney's speech. Several mentioned "You're No Good." I became aware of that song when Linda Ronstadt recorded it in 1974. It captured Carney's statement that great powers had always been hypocrites, and that Canada feels great to be moving on.
Feeling better now that we're through
Feeling better 'cause I'm over you
Learned my lesson, it left a scar
Now I see how you really are
(Chorus)
You're no good, you're no good, you're no good
Baby, you're no good
Others mentioned Kelly Clarkson's 2004 song, "Since U Been Gone."
But since you been gone
I can breathe for the first time
I'm so movin' on, yeah, yeah
Thanks to you
Now I get, I get what I want
Since you been gone
You, with your words like knives and swords
And weapons that you use against me
You have knocked me off my feet again
Got me feeling like a nothing
You can bend, but never break me'Cause it only serves to make meMore determined to achieve my final goalAnd I come back even strongerNot a novice any longer'Cause you've deepened the conviction in my soul
I am strong (strong)
I am invincible (invincible)
I am woman
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog by email go to Https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. The blog is free and always will be.]

1 comment:
Music and poetry communicate feelings and emotions better than talk and bluster. The current crop of Republican House Representatives remind be of some of the worst Greek letter houses I encountered in college. Unfortunately, their sophomoric behavior is having real-world consequences. Your songs communicate the hurt.
Post a Comment