Thursday, October 19, 2023

I suspect Tim Scott will be dropping out

New Hampshire viewers of Fox News get innundated with GOP candidate commercials. Including Tim Scott's. 

That is ending for Scott. His PAC is pulling his ads.

Democrats might presume Tim Scott's black skin means that Republican voters are never going to take him serously as a candidate. Democrats have it backwards. Scott's race and origin story are positives for him.

Tim Scott has a modern  "log cabin" story. He is a Black conservative. He adopted the views and attitudes of the respectable majority culture. His predictable, down-the-line positions are affirmation for White conservatives. Scott "fits in." He doesn't criticize Trump. He is a pro-business, jobs-oriented, tax-cutting, Chamber of Commerce old-style Republican. He says Hamas is bad, that we should be energy dominent, that we should cut corporate and individual taxes while also cutting the deficit. He isn't edgy or new. Qute the opposite. 

He had a brief period when Republican donors and pundits thought this well-rounded candidate would be the favored alternative to Trump and DeSantis. They thought he could make inroads in Georgia and other crossover states. His race and story were the "little extra" Scott brought to the campain. It made sense on paper.

He is lost in the scrum, polling near zero. He is serving up healthy "comfort food" to a primary electorate that has gotten accustomed to a diet of Halloween candy.

Except he says one important, interesting, controversial thing. He condemned Lyndon Johnson's War on Poverty. He didn't complain about its cost or that it was a give-away. He said it was a disaster for Black Americans because it destroyed Black families. Great Society means-testing conditioned assistance to poor women and children on there not being a man in the house. So men left. That destroyed marriages and normalized a culture of children being raised by unpartnered, unwed women. That is a powerful critique, raising serious policy implications for needs-based social programs. His identity and history give him special insight and license to voice this critique, but after a brief mention he moved on to other things. His brand is safe thoughts, not a policy criticism.

His PAC was a prodigious money-raiser. The NH Leadership Summit had a Scott PAC table. That's right: He was represented by his PAC. They had free merchandise. A PAC tee shirt is a strange, uniquely worthless, campaign expenditure. They were offered free and in quantity, if one wished to advertise a PAC. No one wore one. No one else took one. I wanted the photo.


If Republican primary voters want an earnest, low-key pious candidate -- and they don't --  they have the opportunity of choosing Pence or Burgum or Hutchison. But they aren't getting traction, either. 

Apparently Scott's campaign financing is being managed by a third party, and they see the handwriting. Besides, Scott has a senate job to get back to.



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com and subscribe. The blog is free and always will be.]



14 comments:

Mike Steely said...

It doesn't matter how inspirational Tim Scott's story is. Anybody who imagines the Republican White Nationalist base might go for a Black guy is seriously delusional.

Sally said...

This podcast episode says the quiet part out loud.

The US leads the world in single-parent households, and it’s been a disaster.

https://overcast.fm/+WaLFHD8jI

I’ve watched it, seen it, lived it. There’s not much I feel more fervently about.

Jonah Rochette said...

A made-in-the-USA tee shirt? Where do you even find those? And...where's his PAC money going to end up?

Michael Trigoboff said...

Too bad, I liked him. But he just doesn’t have it.

Joe Cambodia πŸ‡°πŸ‡­ said...

Intriguing the way you translated his perception of the great society destroying the black nuclear family is eerily similar to what Oregon’s never ending and generous government assistance programs have done to the white family here at home. Free money has never been prejudicial when it comes to destroying incentive.

Joe Cambodia πŸ‡°πŸ‡­ said...

The tag is made in America πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡Έ, the shirt is made in Thailand Indonesia China or some other cheap labor venue.

John F said...

Reply to JR

What shirt brands are made in USA?
The Definitive 4 Best American-Made T-Shirt Brands

American Giant. American Giant is a clothing brand founded in 2012 in San Francisco, California. ...
Bella + Canvas. Bella + Canvas is a clothing brand founded in Los Angeles, California, in 1992. ...
Royal Apparel. ...
Los Angeles Apparel.

Michael Trigoboff said...

The racial lines in this country are more porous than the left-wing narrative would have you believe. Increasing numbers of “people of color“ are moving towards Donald Trump; which doesn’t quite fit with the left-wing characterization of the Republican party as “racist“, unless you think (looking down at them from atop your horse of great moral height) that those minority voters are idiots.

Mike Steely said...

A little reality check: Comparing the vote in 2020 to 2022, the Republican Party went from 86% White to 85% according to the Pew Research Center. The GOP has one Black senator and five Black representatives in Congress. A few more people of color may be voting Republican, but Republicans aren’t voting for them.

Michael Trigoboff said...

A larger reality check:

Hispanic shifts against the Democrats:

1. In the most recent Wall Street Journal poll, Hispanic voters were split evenly between Democrats and Republicans in the 2022 generic Congressional ballot. And in a 2024 hypothetical rematch between Trump and Biden, these voters favored Biden by only a single point. This is among a voter group that favored Biden over Trump in 2020 by 26 points according to Catalist (two party vote).

2. In the same poll, Biden’s net approval rating among Hispanics was -12 (42 percent approval/54 percent disapproval), the latest in a string of poor approval ratings among Hispanics. Hispanics in the poll favor Republicans in Congress over Democrats on containing inflation and securing the border. They are strongly negative on the economy, with just 25 percent believing it is headed in the right direction, compared to 63 percent who believe it is headed in the wrong direction.

3. A recent 538 analysis of aggregated poll data shows that, while Biden has lost support among all racial groups in the last 9 months, the decline has been sharpest among Hispanics.

4. In Texas, perhaps the Democrats’ most prized target for their theory of the case, Biden’s ratings among Hispanics have been dreadful. A September Dallas Morning News poll had Biden's approval rating among Texas Hispanics at an anemic 35 percent vs. 54 percent disapproval--19 points underwater. His approval rating on handling immigration at the border was even worse--29 points underwater. The latter rating is similar to Biden’s rating on the same issue among Texas Hispanics in the more recent Texas Tribune poll.

5. In the hotly-contested 2021 Virginia gubernatorial election, according to the AP-NORC VoteCast survey (more reliable than the highly flawed exit polls), Democrat Terry McAuliffe actually lost the Latino vote and also lost ground among black and “other race’ (chiefly Asian) voters. This deterioration of nonwhite support also can be seen in analysis of precinct-level results.

6. In the 2020 election, Hispanics, after four years of Trump, gave him substantially more support than they did in 2016. According to Catalist, in 2020 Latinos had an amazingly large 16 point margin shift toward Trump. Among Latinos, Cubans did have the largest shifts toward Trump (26 points), but those of Mexican origin also had a 12 point shift and even Puerto Ricans moved toward Trump by 18 points.

7. Latino shifts toward Trump were widely dispersed geographically. Hispanic shifts toward Trump were not confined to Florida (28 points) and Texas (18 points) but also included states like Wisconsin (20 points), Nevada (18 points), Pennsylvania (12 points), Arizona (10 points) and Georgia (8 points).

8. Pew validated voter data indicate particularly poor performance for Biden among working class (noncollege) Hispanics, with these voters giving Trump a remarkable 41 percent of their vote in 2020. A strong working class Hispanic shift is consistent with detailed precinct-level analysis of the 2020 vote in Hispanic (and Asian) neighborhoods released by the New York Times last December. These data assume special significance in light of the unusually heavy working class character of the Hispanic vote (around 80 percent).

Michael Trigoboff said...

Quoting statistics about 2020 vs 2022 ignores what is happening now, which is what my post, based on current polling, was about.

Mike mentioned “people of color.” It’s been my impression that the category includes Hispanics. Have Hispanics suffered a recent intersectional demotion, lowering their victimhood status? Are they now considered to be “white”, along with Asians? Are Nigerian immigrants (who are doing very well) soon going to become “white” too?

Mike Steely said...

Thanks again, Michael, but I'm quoting data and you're providing polls which are basically speculation. I assume your questions are rhetorical, because they're too confused to answer.

Michael Trigoboff said...

Polls are empirical data, not speculation.

I didn’t realize my questions would confuse you. I will try to speak in simpler terms going forward.

Mc said...

I never vote for anything a Chamber of Commerce backs. They perpetuate greed.