Friday, January 7, 2022

Deja vu.

 "That's the sound of the USA going down the toilet"

       Archie Bunker to Edith


A friend told me I could chill out by watching old shows of "All in the Family" free on Amazon Prime. "It's just like now," the friend said. "Archie says the same things people say now. You can watch it at bedtime because it is soothing. It is history and long past."

Only it isn't past. It is MAGA, Make America Great Again, part one. On my own I stumbled onto "Slow Burn" a multipart history of Nixon and Watergate, free on EPIX streaming service. Watergate isn't past, either.

The opening song is MAGA, a return to an imagined happier economic and cultural era:
Boy the way Glenn Miller played,
Songs that made the hit parade.
Guys like us, we had it made
Those were the days.

And you knew where you were then
Girls were girls, and men were men
Mister, we could use a man like Herbert Hoover again
Didn't need no welfare state
Everybody pulled his weight.

Boy our old LaSalle ran great.
Those were the days.
Slow Burn, the story of Watergate, shows journalist Gail Sheehy today, looking back to describe her interviews 40 years ago in the Astoria neighborhood of Queens, the home of fictional Archie Bunker. The blue-collar workers there loved Nixon and Archie Bunker both, as she wrote then and repeated for this documentary. She said men would say that "they aren't Archie Bunker" but then go on and say exactly what Archie would say.



Nixon had figured out a winning electoral strategy. He combined a "Southern Strategy" of coded racial resentment with populist anti-elitism and that won over blue collar workers in the North. Nixon made wedge issues out of abortion, gender roles, public benefits, and patriotism. He said he would change the liberal Supreme Court. He got the "hardhat," vote. He called liberals "communists." Before there were Trump- Democrats there were Reagan-Democrats, and before that there were Nixon Democrats. 

Slow Burn describes a phenomenon Sheehy found among Nixon's populist defenders. They did not mind that Nixon fought dirty. Trump's supporters, like Nixon's, dismiss mis-behavior because of the larger context of a record they like. Trump, like Nixon, is fighting their enemies.
Over the course of a week Sheehy found them to be angry and demoralized and disconcertingly comfortable with the idea of a police state run by Richard Nixon.


Nixon and Trump said they were bringing "law and order" to bear against dangerous violence in the cities. The anti-war protesters and Black Panthers of the 1970s have their analog in BLM protesters and Antifa. They serve the same political purpose.

Protester being arrested

Then, as now, there is a Congressional Committee to investigate wrongdoing.



Then, as now, they request information from the president on crimes in office.



Then, as now, the president refuses, claiming he is doing it for the good of the country.



Republicans in the Congress defended Nixon until he became an embarrassment for his "expletive deleted" language in the Oval Office and the revelation of undeniable lies about obstructing justice. Trump understands better than Nixon did that his supporters don't care about flouting process or lying, so he does both openly and proudly. They care about getting policies they want. They like that he is a fighter. They like his contempt for his enemies and theirs. 

Trump will be brought down, if ever, not by a group of Republican senators telling him he misbehaved. They know he misbehaves. That is his brand. He will succumb to a younger, better, more cut-throat version of himself, someone who humiliates rivals even better than he does.

Tomorrow: a look at Tucker Carlson.

12 comments:

Mike said...

Perhaps it’s only because this is now, but things do seem different. Back then, the parties were opponents. They were more collegial and could talk with each other because they at least shared a common reality.

Since then, the GOP has degenerated into a party that believes Trump won the election, considers those who claim otherwise ‘enemies’ and tried to overthrow the government. Those arrested for the riot Trump incited are Proud Boys, Three Percenters, Oath Keepers, QAnon and various other white supremacists and neo-Nazis. This is today’s Republican base. In spite of this, some people who consider themselves rational still identify as Republicans. They should be ashamed, but they have no shame.

Rick Millward said...

Awesome. Though you frame it as cultural, what you actually are describing is the long slow decline of the Republican party. Like dry rot, it wasn't visible until Nixon brought it all to the surface. Nixon certainly had the psychological pathology, foreshadowing the racial paranoia of MAGA, and it would seem that after his downfall, heavy handed overreach that was a bit much for the genteel Republicans at the time; they opted for the "kinder, gentler" white glove sociopathy of Reagan and the Bushes(and their naive Democratic collaborators) which worked well until they crashed the economy and brought forth the abominable Obama.

The gloves came off, and here we are.

For what it's worth, I did not watch "All in the Family". The "charming bigot" was another version of "those funny Mafiosos", and "lovable Nazis" that TV finds, unfortunately, profitable, seemingly making the horror acceptable and safe.

Michael Trigoboff said...

Liberal elites impoverish the non-college class, attempt to impose alien far left intersectional values, hurl accusations of “racism” for being concerned about crime and school standards, and then they wonder why there is opposition to their “well-intentioned, virtuous“ policies.

Who created the fertile ground that Nixon and now Trump are exploiting? The woke had better wake up or they can look forward to four more years of a president they won’t be happy about.

Low Dudgeon said...

I enjoy this sort of exercise in comparison/contrast, thanks. And the similarities are quite well-drawn here. As I've said here before, and others have obviously said better elsewhere, historical analysis is often about recognizing what's cyclical, familiar, versus what is notably different in absolute terms.

There are a few contrasts or glosses I'd counterpose to Mr. Sage's list of similarities. First off, I'd say many of the similarities are indeed similar but only after application of the old Daniel Patrick Moynihan construct, "defining deviancy down". So, the "same" but with categorically lower standards.

Trump is not fit to tie Nixon's boot in terms of intellect, self-discipline or even integrity. The same with BLM/Antifa vis a vis the Black Panthers/Weathermen, etc. The Watergate scandal as specific conduct is chump change, with much worse committed multiple times by every single president after Carter.

That means a qualitatively new predicate is needed for those Republican senators today. In part that's because the average even engaged voter knows far less overall out of high school today than 50 years ago, and is correspondingly more jaded. Journalism today is partisan advocacy, pamphleteering really.

Mc said...

The "liberal elites" are why we have computers, vaccinations, x-rays and television.

You're welcome to move to a third-world country that is more to your liking. You don't seem to be contributing to the advance of civilization in this country.

Mc said...

Uh, care to elaborate on the worse conduct committed by "every single president after Carter"?

All presidents have to make decisions that some will find unpopular. And some politicians will try to turn hay into gold, as in the 10 Benghazi hearings and 10s of millions of taxpayers dollars the republicans wasted on Whitewater.

Ralph Bowman said...

The “Archie Bunker” and the “Laverne and Shirley” jobs are gone. Like the lumber mill corporations moved on to cut in Indonesia and left the worker in Cave Junction to make meth and grow weed. Even the closing of Bi Mart pharmacies sucked up by Walgreens leaving the consumer standing in 30 Min lines to find out the drug is not ready. The veil must be ripped away. The masses must attack the corporate structure by buying shares and sitting on investor boards. Creating cooperatives and starving the global giants. How about a Tea Party of burning cargo ships and cyber disruption? You kidding? They just sucked me up into the data base in Utah. Back to identity politics … the only way to never win, but it sure feels good. “Up the ass of the ruling class, power to the peoples..uh uh.”

Michael Trigoboff said...

John von Neumann was a brilliant Hungarian Jewish mathematician who immigrated here in the 1930s, escaping both Nazi and Soviet tyranny. He was a prominent participant in the Manhattan Project. He was a committed anti-communist and an advocate of nuclear deterrence of Soviet aggression.

Von Neumann was a foundational computer scientist; so much so that every computer in current use is based on the “von Neumann architecture” he invented.

Without von Neumann we would not have the computers we all depend on. He was definitely “elite,” but his politics were conservative, not liberal.

Low Dudgeon said...

Mc—

No, instead I’ll happily accept your rather unorthodox position that hiding then destroying some comparatively insignificant audio material, which was nonetheless to be produced under court order, constitutes the worst conduct by a modern President.

Mike said...

‘Tricky Dick’ Nixon was a nasty piece of work, but his attempted burglary pales in comparison to Trump unleashing an armed mob on Congress and trying to overturn an election. You know it’s bad when Dick Cheney, aka ‘Darth Vader,’ slams the GOP for its failure to rebuke Trump as he did yesterday. This is a guy who outed Valerie Plame, an undercover CIA spy, to get back at her husband for exposing some of his lies about Iraq, and yet he’s got more conscience than our current crop of Republicans. Be very afraid.

Ely Schless said...

Michael Trigoboff said...
Liberal elites impoverish the non-college class, attempt to impose alien far left intersectional values, hurl accusations of “racism” for being concerned about crime and school standards, and then they wonder why there is opposition to their “well-intentioned, virtuous“ policies.

Ah, I love the sound of non-elites projecting in the morning!

Not to pick a fight, but that's quite a load of gibberish. Tucker C would be proud. Surprising rhetoric coming from a typically fair-minded, elitist, moderately conservative poster.

Ralph Bowman said...

Guess what? The Archie Bunker’s and Laverne and Shirley’s jobs are gone along with Archie’s fraternal brotherhood union. We can yell about racism and other identity politics but the puppet masters pull the strings, hiding behind the smoke and mirrors of hate go about the business of changing laws, manipulating the cry for more military weapons , taking their money anywhere in the world and exploiting bigger and better. Maybe it’s time for another, patriotic Tea Party that boards the cargo ships and pushes the containers to the bottom of the sea. Of course, that remark has just been picked up by the masters of the deep state’s servers in Utah. Win, win! Oh well, identity politics are fun, lots of banners and painting of faces, lots of yelling …”Up the ass of the ruling class, power to the people, uh,uh”” Our House, Our House!” MAGA MAGA BOOGALOO boogiemen. And quietly General Electric pays no taxes.