Monday, November 13, 2023

Vermin in America.

The important thing is not that Trump sounds like 1930s-era fascists.

The important thing is that crowds cheer him and that most Republican thought leaders are silent.

From Trump's Truth Social

The morning's news is that Trump used language that sounds like Adolf Hitler. Hitler repeatedly used images of vermin, of infection, of national defilement in his speeches and writing. In Mein Kampf: 

With satanic joy in his face, the black-haired Jewish youth lurks in wait for the unsuspecting girl whom he defiles with his blood, thus stealing her from her people. With every means he tries to destroy the racial foundations of the people he has set out to subjugate.

Hitler had a grand explanation of the German condition. They were a great people beset by parasites and vermin. Communists and Jews lurked. The enemy was within.

Trump wrote:


In Cedar Rapids, Iowa, Trump pointed at immigrants. "They drink, they have drugs, a lot of things happening." In Dubuque he said, "It’s the blood of our country; what they’re doing is destroying our country.” 

In Claremont, New Hampshire Trump repeated his Truth Social comment:

We pledge to you that we will root out the communists, Marxists, fascists and the radical left thugs that live like vermin within the confines of our country that lie and steal and cheat on elections. . . . They’ll do anything, whether legally or illegally, to destroy America and to destroy the American Dream.

It is easy to miss the big story. Eight years ago in Rochester, New Hampshire a man asked Trump a question at a rally. The man said Barack Obama was a Muslim and asked what was Trump going to do about it. Trump said, "A lot of people are saying that. We're going to be looking at a lot of different things."

Like the TV news commentators I watched later that evening, I recalled John McCain's reaction when a woman asked him a question with a similar premise. McCain immediately corrected her. Like others, I thought the big event of the evening was that Trump let a false idea go uncorrected, and by his silence he tacitly endorsed it.

Rochester, NH
There was a second thing to notice that I had missed. It was a noisy, rambunctious crowd, but there was no rustling in chairs or moaning or booing or objection to the premise in the man's question. On reflection, that was the big event of the evening.

The GOP is OK with what Trump is doing now, too. There is no rustling in the seats by Republican Senators, Representatives, governors, and conservative media. The Heritage Foundation is silent. The Federalist Society is silent. Except for Christie, candidates still in the Presidential race are silently compliant.

Trump is saying aloud, repeatedly, that he won the 2020 election. He says proudly, repeatedly, that he will change non-political civil service. He says his Justice Department will carry out revenge on political enemies. He says he will prosecute generals who had blocked him when he considered martial law so the U.S. military could stop counting ballots cast for Biden. He says he will round up millions of people, put them in concentration camps, do an expedited denial of their status as amnesty seekers, then deport them.

Trump isn't secretive. 

We have a chicken/egg problem. Republican voters won't be alarmed by the erosion of democratic process if Republican leaders don't speak up. But those leaders are afraid of a primary electorate that believes things those leaders know to be false and dangerous. Trump intimidated the GOP. He exiled critics, calling them RINOs. So the vast majority of GOP leaders stay silent, change the subject, go along, or in the cases of the most cynical, cheerlead and fundraise. 

Those second-level influencers are an essential part of the American constitutional system. They aren't doing their job of putting up warnings and objecting. They are good Republicans, at a time when the country needs good Americans. 



[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com and subscribe. The blog is free and always will be.] 



7 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't understand the dishonesty of this blog. The following Real Republicans have spoken out against the former Dumpster Fire president repeatedly: The Lincoln Project, George Conway (separately), Alyssa Farah Griffin (former member of 45's administration who was on This Week on ABC yesterday), Ana Navarro (a former Bush Republican and frequent media commentator), Liz Cheney (obviously), Chris Christy, Michael Steele (former head of the RNC), the former Chief of Staff (Kelly?) and many others. They are fighting an uphill battle, but they are not silent.

Tabloidism and fake news is not helpful.

Mike Steely said...

The GOP isn’t just OK with what Trump is doing now. They’ve made heroes out of traitors who tried to overthrow the government and made Trump’s Big Lie a litmus test for holding office. Nor is the Heritage Foundation silent. They’ve compiled “The 2025 Project,” a 1,000-page guidebook to help the next Trump administration turn the U.S. into a fascist state.

With a range of candidates to choose from, Republicans overwhelmingly favor the pathological liar with 91 felony counts against him, who promises to use the power of the presidency to heap retribution on the “vermin” holding him accountable for his crimes. According to the polls, half the electorate supports him. What a country we have become!

Dave said...

I don’t get it. Republicans think Hitler thinking, behavior is something to cheer about? Hitler used to symbolize evil, but now he was ok? Christians are in support of this evil man? I’m very disappointed in Americans and if Trump is elected will be in support of the state of Washington leaving the union. Here I am, a person of means who thinks about giving up on the United States. Do I want to be United with Hitler behavior? No, there is a point where too much is too much.

Up Close: Road to the White House said...

"Unknown" makes my point and apparently does not realize it. She has it 180 degrees wrong.

Look who she cites: People who are NOT in the GOP anymore. People who are kicked out. People in exile. The Lincoln Project, Liz Cheney, George Conway. The people who are now IN the GOP are leaders who either cheerlead Trump and who have the unanimous support of the House GOP like Speaker Mike Johnson, or people like Mitch McConnell who is allowed to keep his leadership because now he mumbles about Trump and goes along and says he would support him for re-election.

The great mass of the Party likes Trump. Senator Romney is getting out. Critics are not inside the tent, they are kicked out of the tent. If 17 out of 50 GOP senators had said Trump crossed the line, history would be different. The votes weren't there.

The fact that "Unknown" must pick exiles, as if the people not in the party are the ones in the party, makes my point. When McConnell is replaced it won't be with an outsider. It will be with a Trump collaborator and sycophant. Mike Johnson holds the Speakership. Not Liz Cheney. Read the room.

Peter Sage

Ed Cooper said...

Should the State if Washington choose to leave, I will spend my remaining day or hopefully years working to ally Oregon with them, hopefully to be annexed to British Columbia and form "Cascadia".

Mike said...

The so-called leaders who are IN the GOP aren't just cheerleaders for Trump, but aiders and abettors. Having failed in their attempt to overthrow the government, they're now bent on shutting it down this coming weekend. Happy Holidays.

John C said...


It seems all the current inside GOP “leadership” have adopted Neville Chamberlin’s philosophy of appeasement. And we see how that worked out.

The deconstructionist mentality of MAGA reminds me of a conversation I had about 20 years ago. I was doing rural development volunteer work in El Salvador after the civil war. As part of the peace treaty, the rebel FMLA became recognized as a legitimate political party. One of the former rebel commanders I met was elected Governor of the region where we were working. He said to the effect that being a revolutionary is easy compared to the hard work of governing. Democracy is fickle.

Maybe the fickleness will be its undoing.