Now with every single person I meet I tell them of the love of Christ. He did it all for them. He died and rose again. All these other testimonies, they didn't meet a soft or passive Jesus. Jesus is a man. Especially in the United States he has been misrepresented. There are so many cultural things, as if he's some tolerant guy. That's not the Jesus I met. He's a lion. He's not a lion angry against me. He's a lion for me. He's a mustang on my behalf. He did it all for me.[Question: What did he look like?]Pure fire. Five-eleven, six feet, yet as tall as eternity. He was an ocean of love, yet his eyes were burning white ad red at the same time. Talk about testosterone, a mustang I'm telling you. The lion of Judah. There's a roar within his voice.
Trump, like Jesus, is an expression of strength and retribution. We are seeing a response to feminism in American politics and the feminization of Christianity as expressed in the Sermon on the Mount.
![]() |
| Truth Social images |
Prior to retirement, Cameron was Practice Administrator of Jackson County Physical Therapy for 14 years, following employment as Executive Director of Resolve, a Community Dispute Resolution Center, and Region Manager of SMART, a statewide children’s literacy non-profit. Cam earned a B.A. in English from Mount Holyoke College and attended New College in Berkeley where she studied theology and ethics. Cam enjoys attending theater and volunteering at the Craterian Theater where her husband, Stephen, is Executive Director.
Guest Post by Cameron McCandless
And if you make your system your god, you’ll soon be telling lies in order to remain consistent. ~ Elisabeth Elliot
I know Trump-voting Christians – as do you, Peter – who are well-read, thoughtful, intelligent, and deeply committed to traditional Republican values including free-market trade, small government, and protections for the state of Israel. (Though Trump’s Republicanism is anything but free-market or small government.) Their adherence to Trumpism might be simply put, “The ends justify the means.” The hold-your-nose-and-vote-for-Trump crowd I can understand and respect. The 37 percent of the population that reveres the man I cannot begin to understand.
Maybe the crux of the matter, as Elliot states in the quote above, is the deification of systems, both religious and secular. I’m an independent voter, not comfortable in either party. Religiously, I come from a long line of proud Presbyterians but also align with those who acknowledge mystery more often found where liturgy is practiced. The hard angles of modern evangelicalism, with its partisan certainty, make me queasy. Trump himself makes me positively nauseous.
There are loads of books about how evangelicalism came to be what it is today. One of them is Kristin Kobes Du Mez’s Jesus and John Wayne, How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation. Her most recent book is: Live, Laugh, Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made, from which I got the Elliot quote. Her premise, which pretty much answers the question you asked, is that, beginning in the ‘50’s, an affinity developed between White evangelicals and male cultural icons who project Christian muscularity, “uncowed by political correctness, unafraid to tell it like it is, and willing to do what needs to be done” (Jesus and John Wayne). Chief among these icons is John Wayne (who was not a regular churchgoer, divorced twice, had multiple affairs, and avoided the draft, but who converted to Catholicism on his deathbed.) This appropriation of popular cultural heroes who exercise their competitive and strongman inclinations while exorcising Jesus of the Beatitudes has led to its grotesque and inevitable conclusion in the idolatry of Donald Trump.
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.]




John Wayne was a phony as you can get. He avoided service in WWII so he could act like a tough guy in the movies and get paid big bucks. He once was on tour in the Pacific to entertain the Marines. Some of the Marines joined the service so they could be like Wayne. However, once they figured he was really a coward, they booed him off the stage. He knew why.
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteThank you Cameron McCandless.
Idolatry has sometimes been defined as “making any good thing an ultimate thing”, or outsized in its importance. We see it played out in politics, sports, music and other fan-based social phenomena (think Comic-Con/Cosplay). We are all drawn to idolize something- (including ourselves)
Christian Nationalists like the idea of hanging the Ten Commandments in public spaces like classrooms. The Irony is how they miss the very first Commandment which God gave to Israel which is to avoid all idolatry (ie “have no other gods besides me”).
Many Christian Nationalists also misunderstand Jesus message of his Kingdom. After Jesus rose from the grave and proved that he beat death - and also seemed immune from physical laws (he walked through walls), his Disciples thought that he would finally use his super power to kick the Romans out and restore Israel’s sovereignty. Nope. His kingdom was not a political one. Instead he deputized his apostles to go spread the good news to the world. Even those contemptuous gentiles. In fact until Constantine forced Christianity on everyone and diluted its unique message, the word “Christian” was pejorative and many willingly suffered persecution and martyrdom because they believed in an eternal kingdom that transcends this life.
The Bible teaches that Jesus will return one day to judge rightly. But until then true followers should obey his commands which includes things like loving your neighbor… indeed your enemies. Nation-building in Jesus’ name is simply not supported in his (or his Apostles’) teaching. But of course people can interpret scripture to suit their world-view.
Intriguing post, thank you. Interested to read any thoughts from John C. on this subject too. I have one or two cents to offer.
ReplyDeleteI thought the divide between mainline and fundamentalist denominations cemented over science and Darwin versus Genesis as literally true. Modern evangelicals overlap substantially with fundamentalists but are not synonymous; the former emphasis is less rigid, more worldly, engaging and even somewhat ecumenical in outlook (think Billy Graham?), whereas the latter emphasis is more doctrinaire and even separatist in religious and sociopolitical worldview (think Franklin Graham!). Then there are the Pentecostals, too...
John Wayne's Jesus would hardly turn the other cheek or curb Peter's sword, either at home or with his (theatrical) Green Berets in Vietnam. Overturning the moneylenders' tables, sure. I don't think the foremost modern Christian intellectual, C.S. Lewis, would approve of Trump on any level--even a flawed, "muscular" vessel like King David was nonetheless a heartfelt believer. The lion pics with Trump (where DOES he tithe, anyway?) made me think of the upcoming new adaptation of Lewis' Narnia tales--I read that Aslan/Jesus is reportedly voiced by Meryl Streep!
Don't do unto your Neighbor ...as you're Neighbor will do unto you"
ReplyDeleteThe other side of the Golden Rule…
DeleteEver since the 1970s, there has been an anti-masculine push from feminists and the left. The phrase “toxic masculinity“ is commonly heard from those quarters. Has anyone heard the phrase “toxic femininity“ lately?
ReplyDeleteMasculine aggression is typically expressed physically. Female aggression is typically expressed emotionally/socially. Social media is full of female-style aggression in the form of mobbing and ostracism. One could say, with great justification, that social media is immersed in toxic femininity.
It does not surprise me that in more conservative spaces, such as among evangelicals, resentment among men arises from this negativity directed towards them, and is expressed as a more masculine and aggressive image of Jesus.”
Ever since the 1970s, there has been an anti-masculine push from feminists and the left. The phrase “toxic masculinity“ is commonly heard from those quarters. Has anyone heard the phrase “toxic femininity“ lately?
ReplyDeleteMasculine aggression is typically expressed physically. Female aggression is typically expressed emotionally/socially. Social media is full of female-style aggression in the form of mobbing and ostracism. One could say, with great justification, that social media is immersed in toxic femininity.
It does not surprise me that in more conservative spaces, such as among evangelicals, resentment among men arises from this negativity directed towards them, and is expressed as a more masculine and aggressive image of Jesus.”
Money lenders? Isn't that who you're paying interest to on your credit card? Every time you use your card, you're giving money to a major corporation. Willingly. 24% !!! Some people say Jesus loves you. I say Visa does.
ReplyDelete