The USA made a promise:
Put money into Social Security while you work. Retire and withdraw money roughly proportional to your deposits.The promise no longer pencils out.
Everybody knows the problem. There are solutions, but they are unpopular. The benefit of fiscal solvency is abstract; the solutions are concrete and painful.
Guest Post by Erich Almasy
![]() |
| Cynthia Blanton and Erich Almasy in 1996, about eight years after their story |
In a recent post, commenters noted the size of the Social Security liability and the expected default of its retirement trust fund in late 2032 if current revenue and expenses continue as they are. The long-term Social Security and Medicare shortfalls (kept off the government’s books) dwarf even the annual budget deficit, and both parties’ reluctance to address them directly causes chronic concern among fiscal experts and financial markets.
When my wife and I had our modest consulting firm during the 1980s, we confronted this situation on a micro-scale. One client was a small Caribbean country with a population of about 45,000, our first venture into geopolitics.
We interviewed government officials and businesspeople. Like many in the Caribbean, the country had been, until recently, a British colony with a single source of income: sugar. After independence, small manufacturing and tourism began, but sugar remained dominant, and that was a serious problem because Brazil was selling sugar for less than this country could produce it. We uncovered evidence that the country’s National Bank had been using the Social Security payments to cover the “overdraft” (a quaint British banking term for a deficit) in the national budget. Not only was the country’s own national retirement system, called its Social Security Scheme, breaking, but so was the country. Sound familiar? Only in this country’s case, if the IMF and World Bank found out, all of their loans and development plans would be in serious jeopardy.
Prior consultants had examined the problem. Their reports talked about tourism and local manufacturing but never explained how to get out from under the sugar albatross. The sugar fields and refinery were owned by the National Sugar Company, which employed most of the workforce, paid their wages, and withheld their Social Security Scheme deposits. The National Bank then borrowed to lend to the National Sugar Company to pay those wages, and so on, in a never-ending circle. It was a national Ponzi scheme, only with good intentions. Apparently, we were the first outsiders to discover the problem, and during our final presentation to the Prime Minister and his Cabinet, we uncorked a shocker.
We began, as usual, with references to future opportunities, watched their eyes glaze over, and then said, “But none of this matters, because you’re broke!” That got their attention. We then explained the borrowing-and-deficit cycle in simple but devastating terms. A stricken audience awaited the sword of Damocles until we said, “There is a solution.”
Before independence, largely White plantation owners had managed all the sugar lands (roughly 80 percent of the arable surface). They couldn’t survive on the margins from selling sugar below world prices, so they offered their holdings to the government en masse, and in 1975 the government took them over. A Supreme Court ruling said the country had to pay for the lands. That created an opportunity, since the land was carried on the books at a small value.
Our solution was to revalue the land asset and essentially offset it against the Social Security deficit liability. The asset would pay a small “rent,” enough to cover any Social Security outlays and repay the previous owners. Luckily, the population was young and still far from retirement. Out from under the heretofore insoluble deficit, the government could get back on an even keel, moving sugar workers to new professions and borrowing from international lenders. As it turned out, the country became a leading supplier of second passports and a giant port for cruise ships.
Okay, so why is any of this relevant to the situation the United States faces? First, the borrowing from Peter to pay Paul is quite similar. Our Social Security Trust Fund is an accounting joke, since the money goes right into the general fund in exchange for Treasury IOUs, and the general fund must cover those IOUs as payments come due. Second, the United States has huge, underutilized assets. The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) of the Department of the Interior controls 245 million surface acres (about 11 percent of the U.S. landmass) and 700 million acres of subsurface mineral rights. The Department of Agriculture’s Forest Service controls 193 million acres (about 9 percent of our landmass), mostly forest land. Altogether, the federal government is estimated to own 28 percent of all U.S. land, or about 640 million acres. Traditionally (and because of lobbying and special interests), the grazing, mineral, and oil rights to these lands have been significantly underpriced. Imagine if we charged market rates! Better yet, since so much of this land is blustery, parched desert, imagine building wind and solar farms to harvest its wind and sun.
And it doesn’t stop there. Since 1934, the FCC has controlled the broadcasting spectrum, which, again, was handed to broadcasters free of charge in exchange for serving the public interest, a mandate now largely abandoned. Perhaps greatest of all is the government giveaway of the taxpayer-funded research behind semiconductors and microprocessors, the Internet, Google’s page-ranking algorithm, GPS, CRISPR gene-editing, MRI, smartphones, and mRNA vaccines. We are not really broke; we are just stupid! If we moved America’s assets into the Social Security Trust Fund and had a non-partisan board set proper prices, we could all live happily ever after.
Oh, and make sure there is no upper limit to the Social Security tax, just as there is none for Medicare.
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.]


The government needs to raise FICA taxes on earnings above $184,500. Currently, if someone earns $1 million annually, they only pay 6.2% FICA taxes on the first $184,500 of earnings, and anything above that amount is left untaxed. Conversely, all of that $1 million is taxed for Medicare taxes at 1.45%. For high earners that make more than $184,500 annually, all of their earnings up to an unlimited amount should be taxed for FICA at 6.2%. There are too many high-earning entertainers and sports stars making $40 million annually that don't pay enough FICA taxes. Also, hedge fund managers should be taxed at ordinary income tax rates, and not capital gains rates.
ReplyDeleteLots of good commentary on history, and how we got to this point.
ReplyDeleteThe last paragraph summarizes a solution, but it's not complete:
"Oh, and make sure there is no upper limit to the Social Security tax, just as there is none for Medicare."
We'd also need to put a cap on the maximum monthly benefit payout. Most realize that many of the "rich" don't need this monthly benefit, so just need a cap on the maximum benefit, and an easy way to suspend or simply not take the benefit if it's not needed.
Also, look what Oregon did to fix PERS, by changing the tier system. Tier 1 recipients were promised a guaranteed annual rate of returns, regardless of investment returns. Subsequent tiers tried to correct this.
Oregon has so many fees, deduction limitations, and even more taxes to raise revenues to run the state and to pay promised benefits.
Oregon leadership needs to look deeper to understand how other states seemingly do more for residents while taxing them less.
Oregon and its city and local governments also face problems, and will also face even more as "the rich" know there are lower taxes in other states and it may just be cheaper to visit when wanted and needed, rather than use Oregon as a residence and tax domicile.
That's why I moved to Florida. No state income tax, no property tax on cars, no mandatory inspection on cars, and now a proposal by the governor to eliminate all property taxes. And the sun is always out.
ReplyDeletePeter C, I looked up Florida’s financials and they look quite good in spite of such a favorable tax structure. You guys are AAA credit rated with one of the lowest debt per resident.Property taxes make up about 35% of the total tax revenue of the state but they are collected and used locally. 70% of local tax revenue comes from property taxes to fund police, fire, roads and schools. Seems like eliminating property taxes entirely would essentially defund all those, and it’s not like the state will come to the rescue. How attractive does that sound?
Delete