"Why is everybody always picking on me?"
The Coasters, 1959
Maybe I need to pay more in taxes.
I won't like it.
Like it or not, we are all in this together. The country needs to work for pretty much everyone. Otherwise, discord.
There is a great deal more inequality in America than there was in the country I grew up in. I was born in 1949, at the front end of the baby boom. There was a giant middle class, and White people could enter it if they had a full-time job. People with jobs could own a home. There was income inequality, of course, but people with professional jobs did not live conspicuously better than people who worked at the lumber mills. Better, yes. They drove Cadillacs instead of Chevys and had two-bathroom homes instead of one, but psychologically they were in the same place: middle-class Americans.
Children of millworkers could go to college, get a professional job, and buy a Cadillac.
Things are different now, and not in a good way for our country. It shows up in bad ways:
-- We are in a new gilded age of very wealthy people who hold both economic and political power.
-- Young people find the elevators of upward social mobility very expensive. Measured against the minimum-wage jobs available to students, my local regional state university, Southern Oregon University, is as expensive as the most expensive private colleges in America were in 1967.
-- The indicia of a middle-class life -- a home, access to health care, a reliable car, children, a 40-hour workweek, a comfortable-enough retirement at 65 -- are a stretch. Or out of reach.
The result is widespread resentment and frustration. People feel the world is stacked against them, rigged to benefit someone else. Christians think they are picked on. White people think they are picked on by DEI. Blacks, Hispanics, Muslims, and Asians think they are picked on. Women feel picked on. LGBTQ people feel picked on. Cisgender heterosexuals feel picked on. Immigrants and second-generation Americans feel picked on. Poor people feel picked on. Prosperous people feel picked on. Even billionaires feel picked on.
JFK’s 1961 inaugural address spoke of a shared burden to survive and thrive as a country -- ask what you can do for your country. Today that seems dated and naive. Don’t be a sap. New York tycoon and candidate Donald Trump bragged that he didn’t pay taxes. “That makes me smart.” He got elected in 2016 after saying that.
I grew up in the shadow of the total mobilization of a world war. In WWII businesses owned by rich old men had been protected by young men drafted into the military and by civilians in war factories. Those soldiers had earned a place at the table. A very progressive tax structure reflected a sense that every part of the society owed something to all the others.
Billionaires don’t want to share and redistribute their wealth. Nor do millionaires. They feel picked on. Look out for number one.
Something has got to change. A nuclear war would push reset. Less disruptive would be an attack on the power grid. A month without electricity, food, water, or health care would remind comfortable people who the essential people are. A pandemic as contagious as measles and as deadly as Ebola would do it, too. We would all need the cooperation of each other.
Something fundamental needs to change in how income is distributed.
It wouldn't kill wealthy people to pay more in taxes. But they won't like it and will resist it.
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog to your email go to: https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. Don't pay. The blog is free and always will be.]


Too much income inequality =revolution. Throw in AI disruption and it’s complicated even more. AI values some humans more than others. Favorites are Pakistani, Chinese, and by far the most valued, Japanese, so AI may resolve things for us.
ReplyDeletePeter, you're a millionaire living in a 4,000 sq. ft. house. Do you need that big of a house? You probably own 3 cars. Do you need 3 cars? You give your money to liberal political candidates. How much do you give to the poor? You're a lot of talk, and no action.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment, which is anonymous but written in the style of Curt Ankerberg, a carful reader of this blog. Thanks, Curt!! In fact My house is several hundred square feet bigger than 4000 square feet, and that does not count the covered decks, the swimming pool shelter, the gazebo for the hot tub, and the extra out-building for woodworking. Nor my farm and its home, its out- buildings, its storage unit, and barn. I do in fact own three cars; good guess. I keep a vehicle at the farm for tasks where I need to haul things or get it dirty. Plus tractors. And I do give money to liberal political candidates, pretty much any local one who asks for it. Plus federal, state, and local ones. Plus ballot issues. My primary donations go to SOU, Harvard, Asante, youth reading and education, and local causes involving justice and inclusion. I never expected to make any money. My goal in my youth was to make the world better by increasing social justice through politics. I and my generation fell fall short of my aspirations. I have an acute consciousness of the arbitrary way that incomes are distributed. I don't consider my former work at Morgan Stanley to be any harder than the job of being a nurse or teacher, for example, but as it happens it throws off a great deal more money for practitioners that are good at it. Apparently I was. I was surprised at how unfair that was, since I carried a labor and value notion of income distribution. Hard, dangerous jobs should pa the most. It simply is not how it works, I learned from experience, In a capitalist economy like ours, entrepreneurship is financially reworded. Helping clients be happy with how I managed their money was not particularly hard for me, for some reason. Being a financial advisor is less "hard" than hoeing a long row of weeds out of melons, but it is 10,000 times more financially rewarding. It took a long time for me to get used to that reality. I dealt with it be being generous to politicians and nonprofits,and now by paying farmworkers very, very well. Maybe sometime I will post about occupations and incomes. For the information of readers unfamiliar with Curt Ankerberg, he is a frequent candidate for local offices. He has some local fame for being an angry voice of Republican anti-Chamber of Commerce trolling. He writes me five to ten times a week with insults accusing me and fellow Democrats of murder, pedophilia, and homosexual acts. He is a curious guy. Intelligent, but often incautious and intemperate. When he sends me comments involving harming me or anticipating with glee my death, I send it to the Medford police to add to their file of material on him. Police say I should not be worried, that he won't murder me. But if he does, they tell me that then, and only then, would they have justification for taking away his concealed carry permit.
Delete“Income inequality” the fashionable cri de couer bespeaks class envy more than it does the auspices of a practical solution to the nation’s very real economic hazards. Taxing the hell out of the wealthy would scarcely dent the national debt or deficit. Even military spending is not a major culprit. Entitlement spending, i.e., entitlement borrowing, is the Damocles sword hanging over the nation. Okay, that’s what I’ve read anyway.
ReplyDelete