What will we know for sure about what President Trump called "the little excursion in Iran?"
There will be disagreements about the Iran Memo of Understanding and eventual peace settlement.
I expect to be lied to by both sides.
Here is what I think we know for sure:
-- We didn't get regime change in Iran. The same team is in place, but now with younger people with a fresh sense of national purpose and pride.
-- The bombing of the girls school and the death of 100-plus schoolgirls will not go away. A hundred years from now Iranians will remember that we bombed a school for girls.
-- As with Obama's Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, the eventual Trump nuclear deal will leave Iran wanting to get nuclear material. The technology is available. But they have learned that they have something better than a nuclear bomb, which would invite nuclear retaliation: They can hold the world's economy hostage by threatening the Strait of Hormuz.
-- Before the start of the war on February 28, the Strait of Hormuz was an international waterway, with free passage for everyone. Now the Iran and Oman control the strait, and we are negotiating to have it be free of Iranian tolls, while Iran is negotiating to regulate them with administrative and environmental fees.
-- Before the start of the war the U.S. was the security guarantor for the oil-rich countries of the region. We had a deal with them: They trade in petrodollars and keep oil flowing to the world; we keep safe their glass cities, luxury hotels, hedge fund headquarters, and energy infrastructure. That is over. The war proved we cannot protect them. The protection comes from making cooperation arrangements with Iran.
-- The U.S. military is huge, but ineffective. The weapon systems of World War II and the Cold War are obsolete. A thousand drones at $10 million are more effective than one aircraft carrier at $5 billion. And you don't need to sink the aircraft carrier. You just have to scare the insurance companies that insure oil tankers.
-- The U.S. burned its allies with insults and trade wars, so it does not lead a coalition of democracies. When it really counts, the U.S. is on its own.
-- The U.S. got led by Israel and is now scrambling to unwind the mess it got itself into. Israel has become a political liability. U.S. hawks on behalf of Israel have been discredited. Even Trump is abandoning them, and no credible American politician will try to replace Trump as a full-throated champion of Israel.
-- The U.S. has a glass jaw militarily. The way for supposed small powers and middle powers to end wars with the U.S. on favorable terms is to cause political distress for the president. The weak spot for the U.S. is the next election.
-- President Trump and conservative media will call this a tremendous victory for Trump and the USA.
[Note: To get daily delivery of this blog by email go to Https://petersage.substack.com. Subscribe. The blog is free and always will be.]


Trump may have become the "Peace President" whether that was his intension. Taiwan may realize they are alone in the South China Sea, their government and people haven't realized that situation already. Our chip industry may find itself "regulated" by what China allows in the way of commerce. The unwinding of American Power has begun. What does the world's largest GDP really mean anymore? We find ourselves in a position where allies and enemies alike can hold our economy hostage on a whim. The only fear I have is Trump may play the nuclear card on Iran. Then what...?
ReplyDeleteSounds like a profound defeat. The biggest loser is Isreal coordinating with US in the future.
ReplyDeleteHaving an impetuous fool for a president has consequences.
Very well said, Peter. But Trump has announced a deal is imminent 38 times before. Every time he does, the price of crude oil goes down and when it turns out to be his usual BS, the price rises. If this turns out to be something more than another market manipulation, it isn't likely to leave us any better off than the deal President Obama had already made through international diplomacy.
ReplyDeleteToday's post heading at my own preferred conservative news/punditry site, Power Line Blog: "The Terms Of Our Surrender".
ReplyDeleteFrom the piece: "To think that our military accomplishments snatched this defeat from the jaws of victory is mind-boggling".
The U.S. got played by Israel. Fixed it for you.
ReplyDelete